I've done nearly 33,000 with DSG and for the first 1,000 only used D, then D and S until about 30k miles. Having done a Drivetrain driving course, I now use paddles most of the time and only D when in crawling traffic. I don't like the soft feel of the floor stick and find the paddles much more instant and direct. I wish they were much bigger and extended both above and below - It can be tricky entering a roundabout in 1st and needing 2nd while on nearly full lock - Perhaps I should pop into S for that but she's very eager particularly as remapped.