isnt this the most pointless topic??

comparing standard v standard in a straight line race?
even if you knew nothing about cars and just looked at the standard manufactures performance figures you can see a VR6 is clearly the faster car.
why would a 2.8/9 VR be slower than a 1.8 16v - yes it is surprisingly close until you head into triple figures but it is clear to anyone that a VR has PLENTY more top end power and speed. and yes i have 16v a 1.8 an a 2.0 an i know ppl who own 2.8s an 2.9 VRs.
if the original question had been, on track X which would do the fastest lap then yes that has some relevence and would be worthy of discusion- bigger car bigger engine an worse handling vs lighter car smaller engine an better handling.