Yeah, I found that comment a bit nonsensical, but anywho...
I think on Golfs, really either look good, just it depends on personal preference.
What I don't like, tho is the Bloody Jetta front on Golfs, and to a lesser extent the Rallye front, but the worst is that twin square light on the really rare golfs by some vw tuner, the one where there are only three in the country, eww.