Lot of opinion on this one chaps. I have been lucky enough to own both a MK5 GTI and two MK5 R32,S. To compare them as the same is incorrect.They are both toatally different cars in their characteristics.The GTI is a great car very nimble excellent chassis and the engine is a peach.The 32 is a totally different driving expeirence all together.Yes the car is heavier but it is still nimble enough to leave almost or keep up with anything due to the haldex. Can i also say my 32 is getting quicker as it "loosens up".Mine is a manual and i do admit you have to catch the clutch just right for fast getaways etc but the traction never ceases to amaze me even with the traction off.
The GTI does feel lighter on its feet but that said once i,d driven the 32 i was hooked and had to have one,the noise is enough for me!!
Also the 32 does seem to get more "street cred" tham the GTI,I constatnly get asked when refuelling,parked up etc about the 32.EVO mag got it right about the image of the R32 though.There seems to be too many GTIs kcking about and i think they have lost a bit of their exclusivity.
Even so both are excellent cars guys so lets not fall out!!
Could their be a bit of jealousy GTI owners?? LOL.
Cheers
Chrissyr32.