I used Goodyear Eagle F1 a few times. Currently on Michelin PS5 but…..at next change I might go back to Goodyear mainly because I think they have better rim protection. Anyone got a view on the rim protection claims?
If it were me I'd change all four. Seems silly to replace three. I'd feel much more comfortable knowing I'd got a new set all round. Just keep the one as a spare rather than bin it.