The mk7 certainly does seem to be highly regarded by die hard golf fans.
It has also caught the imagination of other buyers- it’s my first VW- I’ve previously seen golfs/ vw brand as rather dull- not this mk7.
Have changed cars every 3 years for last 18 years, and each time am open to the alternative and walk the forecourts and do the diligence on all the cars in the sector I look towards (hatchback with some performance attributes)
Prior to the MK 7 it was back to back Audi Quattro and was very close to going for 3rd when someone on the Audi forum put up a link for the upcoming MK 7 Performance models - A lot of what was paying for on the Audi was standard and the MK 7 looked great in 5 door where I had been putting up with the discomfort of 3 Door as not liked the Sport Back - Also the ride was quite firm on my Quattro and the new MQB platform and the v2 DCC seemingly would remedy that annoyance also, and when added in that could afford DSG also (to try for first time) I was swayed to the MK 7 GTD (did many more miles then)
At 3 years admit that only looked at one car, the R having loved the GTD so much and the R was my ride for last 3 years.
This time around, was very open to the opposition, got quite excited about the A35 AMG, really wanted it to wow me, but when dug deeper just felt overall that the MK 7 was still the better package especially when added in the value (after adding all options you would want on the A35)
Think many are loyal to the MK 7 based on just how hard it is to look beyond it, as even the latest on market can only compare but not beat out a 7 year model - Also it seems the MK 8 will not drive much differently, so again that makes the MK 7 as the model that has set the curve.
The way seeing cars going think the TCR might be the first keeper as drive will be all that ever would need, and its styling will remain timeless.