oh ho ho, this is going to go well...
Oh no it's not!
Logic jim suggests that the newest must be the best but different things float peoples boats, i myself like every model except for the mk4 which i think looks fat and dumpy, others will disagree.
I own a mk3 but if i had the choice it would be a mk1 campaign all day long.
Correct. (but not as a daily)
In some ways golfs got better with age, but generally better all rounders as opposed to better GTI's.
MK1 = Awesome GTI, MK2 = Slightly More Refined Awesome GTI, MK3 = Modern Car and less of a GTI, MK4 = Refined Car and modern GTIness if you got the 20vT. MK5= Good All Round up to date GTI that has very little in common with it's older siblings and same goes for the 6 (as it's practically the same car)