Ok... very varied and passionate responses on both sides... just in the spirit of GolfGTI.co.uk

Here's my view:

I reckon they are both brilliant.

The black one looks great with the all black approach - bit youthful perhaps but I like it.
The white one I'm not such a fan of but that's purely because I've seen too many white (black alloys) cars recently.
As for them being fakes... they are still real golf's and if someone wants to jazz their car up to look like a GTI/GTD then it's
a) good to have such enthusiasm so good work
b) nice to see that you've went for a OEM approach rather than Halfords bits
c) a compliment to the GTI/GTD that you wish to emulate such models.
For whatever reason you are not running a higher spec model - not my concern, but congratulations on presenting two nonetheless good looking and individual approaches to mk6 Golf ownership.