The warranty guy was saying that he had never had seen 4 or 5 cases where it was the same & each of those had been resolved by VW, He then told me I would need to come back another day so he could check the depth of my paint & make sure it had never been painted,
On my second visit he proceded to check the depth, Firstly on the panel in question the reading was 160 microns, Once he saw this he said "its a bit thick that paint, I think its bee sprayed at some point"
But talking politely to him I persuaded him to check other parts of the car, Surprisingly they were 140 - 160 microns, With this he started to look at the seals on the boot, His conclusion was that it had not been repaired.
Told me it would probably be a waste to submit it to VW as they have become very funny lately & for me not to build my hopes up. I Carried on talking to him & slowly won him around & got him to submit the claim anyway & today got the call saying they will do it