VWR Panel filter or APR Induction

[jdjd]

Just looking at buying some form of induction today. Not sure if the panel filter would be better then the APR carbon intake.
Points i notice quickly

VWR Filter           
Only about £90
Easy install , Easy removal

But does it work?

APR
Cost £250
Claims actual bhp increase not just torque like the vwr filter
Optional Turbo Downpipe at another £150

Basically dont want to spend my money on something im only going to find isn't up to the job as I go along with more modifications.
 Any thoughts or opinions. Or better yet does anybody have any of the above

VWR http://www.volkswagenracing.co.uk/Golf%206%20Pages/Golf%206%20Intake%20Panel.html

APR INTAKE http://www.goapreu.com/products/intake_carbonio_20tsi.htm

[Das Auto]

I have the APR carbonio Intake it is very good as for the bhp increase im not sure vecause i had it done at the same time as the remap so not sure and i havent been on a RR