I bought Car and AutoCar yesterday...
Both give 4 stars, but the Car review seemed much more positive. They loved the car and said it was better on all counts than the GTI apart from the price. I think the price is whats preventing 5 stars in most reviews.
AutoCar however didn't seem to understand that its supposed to be a 'grown up' hot hatch and seemed to be more taken with the ASBO looking RS and the nasty French car! They also said that the Megane was much faster - and then admitted the Golf had only done 500 miles and not been run in!
Hey ho... I'm sure we'll get an AutoExpress one in the next week or two!