If you get a debadged grille DEFINETLY get an eyebrow spoiler, it looks so much better.
I really dont like the quad debadged grilles - i'm guessing since they're quite rare thats a popular opinion!
I sprayed up all my bumpers with black bumper paint that cost very little from Halfords, doesnt wash off either. Although obviously you've gotta spend a bit of time masking it off etc, even better if you remove the bumpers
here's my old golf with debadged grille and eyebrow spoiler - looked ace

(I have a GTi with quad grille now, I like it a lot more- I think it varies from car to car which looks better really)