Author Topic: forever changing gear  (Read 1118 times)

Panthera

  • Guest
forever changing gear
« on: 02 October 2012, 11:05 »
I seem to be finding that I am forever changing gear in my GTi.  Now I read an article in CSMA magazine where a guy who has a 6 speed box and his wife has a 5 speed box that he is forever having to change gear in his car when slowing a small amount and then re-accelerating. Whereas in his wife 5 speed box, you don't have to keep changing as there seems to be a better gear ratio and engine/torque match. He also went on to say that one of the reasons for manufactures using a 6 speed gear box was to save fuel when cursing at motorway speeds. 

Anyway, I just think that manufactures are giving new cars not enough low down/midrange torque when in the higher gears. My last car had max torque (295ft lb) at 1950rpm and a 6 spd G/box and in any gear it would pull with the lightest of throttle prods.  Now, I suppose you could buy a 'Denziel' fuel of Satan car, but I find these just as bad, if not worse.  I have driven a few diesel cars, (not performance diesel models I might add) and find them almost worse for low down torque in a higher gear. I find that you have to drop down at least 2 cogs to keep going and not labouring the engine or 'stuttering', whereas in a petrol you don't really need to. Like 25-30mph in a diesel you would need to be in either 2nd or 3rd whereas in a petrol car at the same speed you could be quite happy in 4th or even 5th.   

And another thing, when I want to accelerate in my GTi, and give it a boot full it seems to be hesitant like the old TVR's  - "are you sure?'...'Yes'..."okay then"...and the the power comes in.  I am sure VW designed it like that as a safety measure. Perhaps I should try a disable the ESP and see if I get the same result.

Sorry for this rant, just wanted to get it off my chest.

Offline tweed

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 5,379
Re: forever changing gear
« Reply #1 on: 03 October 2012, 00:04 »
You need a remap  :grin:

Oh and 6 gears in a gti is for acceleration. Want to drive around town in 5th? Then drive the wife's car.

Untitled by tweedub, on Flickr

Offline dTEA

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,443
  • back in an MK5
Re: forever changing gear
« Reply #2 on: 06 October 2012, 06:36 »
Contraction within the post anyway...you say manufacturers make cars with 6 gears for around fuel economy and you can drive yours in 5th. That's the point. Your car is designed with a power curve and for the GTI with a turbo that needs time to spool up. Go and drive a NA 200bhp car like an integra or Civic and they move on the rev counter faster but the power is all near the top end.

Learn to find the sweet spot N the GTI is rewarding....presuming its a MK5 as MK4s all need a remap :evil:

Edition 30 / T5 T32 Kombi