He got the one from the non Vw dealers and it drives spot . I know maybe the other one would be ok but no service for 3 years vs 1 a year . The car drives fantastic apart from the odd stone chip he’s a happy lad . If anything my dsg on my car is noticeably louder than he’s , he’s seems to be very quiet . But thanks for everyone s advice , it Gave him a lot to think about and helped him with his decisions. He will be joining this site soon, so I’m sure he will have loads of questions lol