Now I am aware that the subject of aftermarket filters has been done to death

but I have a slight variance on the theme and was wondering about the perceived wisdom of the masses!

I need to do some work on the air intake on the 8v, as I think that is where the oil was getting into the intake on my day at Brands, and remove the breather and fit a catch tank. So I noticed another Mk2 on the day who had a bonnet vent fitted and was getting a direct cold air feed from that. Thinking about this it makes great sense, but I was talking to a number of very knowledgeable people who said that a NACA duct would be a better fit. It would not upset the airflow over the car and could be placed further towards the front of the bonnet and thus in a high pressure area. The idea would be to create a fibreglass (?) box in the engine bay to isolate the filter and feed this from the front edge via a 3“ NACA duct towards the front of the bonnet. This then leads me onto the argument about best / least restrictive filter arrangement. Now IN THIS INSTANCE with a proper box to control the airflow and any excessive noise would it make sense to fit some form of cone filter or just box round the existing box?
Over to you all. Many thanks,
Jon