GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk5 => Topic started by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 11:54

Title: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 11:54
As title says, after 15k, my boots are about shot and will be going for change next week after service..
The car is on a maintenance contract, but going from previous contracts, they can be slightly flexible on changing brand...
On my old LCR I changed from the original Pirellis to Conti sport 2's and I could not believe the difference!!!  :shocked: Hardly ever lost traction under normal driving (it was remapped too). Are these wise for the ED30, or what is the best choice for you boys..?
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungsten carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little, so obviously a very hard compound. But can't help thinking they could grip a little better.. :sad: So idealy I am looking for something that is a little softer (more grip), but something that I won't wear out in a fortnight..  :grin:
Suggestions please?  :wink:

P.S. I know I could do a search, but, well, if i'm honest, I can't be arsed!  :grin: :grin: :grin:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: luca on 30 September 2008, 12:01
Ben i have the continental conti sport 2's. They are pretty good in the dry but not that good in the wet. Its pretty hard to get a tyre that is very good in wet and dry.
I would go for the goodyears next.
If funds permit next year i will run toyo r888 in the summer with the team dynamics and some goodyears eagle f1 for the winter on my pescaras :wink:.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: bobotheclown on 30 September 2008, 12:03
My Michelin Pilot Primacy's are pretty good, an have read that the Michelin Pilot Sports are good too. Costco (if you are a member or know someone who is) are doing the Pilot Sports for £116 each.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 12:07
Doesn't matter to much on cost (within reason), as I don't pay..  :laugh:

Did you say you have Conti's on yours now Luca?
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: SteveP on 30 September 2008, 12:10
Compared to the Bridgestones and Pirellis I had on my previous GTI I think the Michelins I have now are far the best all rounders :smiley:

Like you I have found the mich's to last a very long time, the Bridgestones and Pirelli both lasted less than 9K for me.

Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 12:13


Like you I have found the mich's to last a very long time, the Bridgestones and Pirelli both lasted less than 9K for me.


Bloody hell, don't want to be going through a set in less than 10/11k really.. What mileage have you got out of the Michelins Steve, just to compare..?
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 12:14
As title says, after 15k, my boots are about shot and will be going for change next week after service..
The car is on a maintenance contract, but going from previous contracts, they can be slightly flexible on changing brand...
On my old LCR I changed from the original Pirellis to Conti sport 2's and I could not believe the difference!!!  :shocked: Hardly ever lost traction under normal driving (it was remapped too). Are these wise for the ED30, or what is the best choice for you boys..?
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little, so obviously a very hard compound. But can't help thinking they could grip a little better.. :sad: So idealy I am looking for something that is a little softer (more grip), but something that I won't wear out in a fortnight..  :grin:
Suggestions please?  :wink:

P.S. I know I could do a search, but, well, if i'm honest, I can't be arsed!  :grin: :grin: :grin:

Which type of Michelin?  If they are the Pilot Exalto PE2, then the Pilot Sport PE2 would be considerably better.  And I'll say it again, the Mich PS2 IS the best tyre in the world.  They are fitted as standard to a whole host of cars, from Audis, Porsches, through to the Bugatti Veyron.  There is a chap in the Isle of Man who has a seriously tuned B5 RS4, and regularly does 200mph on the island, and states that only the Mich PS2s are good enough.

As you have already discovered, Pirellis are fooking shyte, and actally fookin lethal.

And whilst many on here and elsewhere will rave about the Goodyears, they too IMVHO are shyte too, because they have unresolved issues which cause adverse handling traites, and will actually cause the ESP to kick in.  Owners on this forum have reported this directly to Goodyear UK, and these same issues were reported in various car mags - yet Goodyear do fcuk all about it.  Finally, Goodyears (of the size and type relevant to the GTI) have NO OEM approvals or fitments.

Appart from Michelins, the only other tyre I would recommend is the latest Continental - the ContiSportContact3s, which also have OEM approvals and fitments from Audi and Porsche.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: The Wheel Man on 30 September 2008, 12:16
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little,

On the side wall of your tyre you will have a bit that says something like this "Traction A,  Temperature A, Treadwear 280.  What is the number you have on the treadwear?  Im not sure on the scale that its is based but im pretty sure that the lower the number the softer the compound.  For example the Toyo 888's are 100 and my Conti 3's are 280

To be honest i cant complain about the conti 3's that i have although i have not had any other tyre fitted to the GTI as yet so this is a somewhat flawed opinion
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 12:16
My Michelin Pilot Primacy's are pretty good, an have read that the Michelin Pilot Sports are good too. Costco (if you are a member or know someone who is) are doing the Pilot Sports for £116 each.

Pilot Primacys are NOT suited to the GTI, or any hot hatch or performance car.  They are specifically designed for large luxury limos, such as the Merc E and S classes, Audi A8, VW Phaeton, etc.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: SteveP on 30 September 2008, 12:17


Like you I have found the mich's to last a very long time, the Bridgestones and Pirelli both lasted less than 9K for me.


Bloody hell, don't want to be going through a set in less than 10/11k really.. What mileage have you got out of the Michelins Steve, just to compare..?

Just other 13K now and they have probably got at least another 6-7K to go  :smiley:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Saint Steve on 30 September 2008, 12:18
Whats your honest opinion On Dunlop Sportmax??   ( gets ready for it! ) worn fronts that are on about 4mm, and ive posted about esp making me almost headbutt the steering wheel when trying to excellerate hard.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: 182_blue on 30 September 2008, 12:24
Goodyear asymetrics are fine on mine, i has Michelin ps2's on my old car and they never felt quite right, the conti 2 originals felt better if im honest
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 12:25


Like you I have found the mich's to last a very long time, the Bridgestones and Pirelli both lasted less than 9K for me.


Bloody hell, don't want to be going through a set in less than 10/11k really.. What mileage have you got out of the Michelins Steve, just to compare..?

Just other 13K now and they have probably got at least another 6-7K to go  :smiley:
Bloody hell, quite a difference then mate..
To be honest I could probably get another 2k out of mine, as they are not on wear bars yet, but the traction at the min is getting pretty sh!te ) compared to when they were newer, so just want them changed asap..
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 12:26
As title says, after 15k, my boots are about shot and will be going for change next week after service..
The car is on a maintenance contract, but going from previous contracts, they can be slightly flexible on changing brand...
On my old LCR I changed from the original Pirellis to Conti sport 2's and I could not believe the difference!!!  :shocked: Hardly ever lost traction under normal driving (it was remapped too). Are these wise for the ED30, or what is the best choice for you boys..?
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little, so obviously a very hard compound. But can't help thinking they could grip a little better.. :sad: So idealy I am looking for something that is a little softer (more grip), but something that I won't wear out in a fortnight..  :grin:
Suggestions please?  :wink:

P.S. I know I could do a search, but, well, if i'm honest, I can't be arsed!  :grin: :grin: :grin:

Which type of Michelin?  If they are the Pilot Exalto PE2, then the Pilot Sport PE2 would be considerably better.  And I'll say it again, the Mich PS2 IS the best tyre in the world.  They are fitted as standard to a whole host of cars, from Audis, Porsches, through to the Bugatti Veyron.  There is a chap in the Isle of Man who has a seriously tuned B5 RS4, and regularly does 200mph on the island, and states that only the Mich PS2s are good enough.

As you have already discovered, Pirellis are fooking shyte, and actally fookin lethal.

And whilst many on here and elsewhere will rave about the Goodyears, they too IMVHO are shyte too, because they have unresolved issues which cause adverse handling traites, and will actually cause the ESP to kick in.  Owners on this forum have reported this directly to Goodyear UK, and these same issues were reported in various car mags - yet Goodyear do fcuk all about it.  Finally, Goodyears (of the size and type relevant to the GTI) have NO OEM approvals or fitments.

Appart from Michelins, the only other tyre I would recommend is the latest Continental - the ContiSportContact3s, which also have OEM approvals and fitments from Audi and Porsche.
Cheers for the ridiculous amount of usefull info again TT..  :wink:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 12:27
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little,

On the side wall of your tyre you will have a bit that says something like this "Traction A,  Temperature A, Treadwear 280.  What is the number you have on the treadwear?  Im not sure on the scale that its is based but im pretty sure that the lower the number the softer the compound.  For example the Toyo 888's are 100 and my Conti 3's are 280

To be honest i cant complain about the conti 3's that i have although i have not had any other tyre fitted to the GTI as yet so this is a somewhat flawed opinion
Will have a look in a bit mate and let you know.. :wink:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 12:31
Whats your honest opinion On Dunlop Sportmax??   ( gets ready for it! ) worn fronts that are on about 4mm, and ive posted about esp making me almost headbutt the steering wheel when trying to excellerate hard.

They are crap (but not "overrated" like Pirellis).  :sick:  Weak carcasses (just like Pirelli and Vredstein), which make them suffer from static deformation.  They also have quite a hard tread rubber, which is why they don't grip too well.  :wink:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: bobotheclown on 30 September 2008, 12:32
My Michelin Pilot Primacy's are pretty good, an have read that the Michelin Pilot Sports are good too. Costco (if you are a member or know someone who is) are doing the Pilot Sports for £116 each.

Pilot Primacys are NOT suited to the GTI, or any hot hatch or performance car.  They are specifically designed for large luxury limos, such as the Merc E and S classes, Audi A8, VW Phaeton, etc.

Oh man, really? These are what came with the car from the dealership. It was a brand new factory build. I'm going to change them as soon as I have the cash. Cheers for the heads up T_T. Always appreciate the advice you give.  :smiley:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: E30M3 on 30 September 2008, 12:36
Ben defintly go for the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric one of the best tyres if not the best and i'm used Michelin Sport cups !

Failing that get Michelin PS2's or the Bridgestone equivalent.

All three of the above tyres are great in the wet/dry and give a good ride !

Judging by the high mileage you do, semi slicks out of the eqaution ??  ie Michelin Pilot Sport Cups / Toyo T1 R s ?


i would definatly go for the Goodyear Asymmetric , thats whats going on the CH's .
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: john_o on 30 September 2008, 12:36
Heres my previous thoughts
http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=91265.0 (http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=91265.0)

Exaltos are mediocre imho
I'd get the PS2 if possible (check you get the right version!)

I dont share TT thoughts on the F1's , but then again I have never fitted them to the GTI so I cant fully refute them either.

Cost will prob help you decide  :shocked:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: WhiteGTI on 30 September 2008, 12:38
And whilst many on here and elsewhere will rave about the Goodyears, they too IMVHO are shyte too, because they have unresolved issues which cause adverse handling traites, and will actually cause the ESP to kick in.  Owners on this forum have reported this directly to Goodyear UK, and these same issues were reported in various car mags - yet Goodyear do fcuk all about it.  Finally, Goodyears (of the size and type relevant to the GTI) have NO OEM approvals or fitments.

Appart from Michelins, the only other tyre I would recommend is the latest Continental - the ContiSportContact3s, which also have OEM approvals and fitments from Audi and Porsche.

What you say above is very true, no disputing at all. I was one of those that commented how sh!te my Goodyears were during the wearing in phase (which as discussed before seemed to take way too long, and could be labelled as borderline dangerous)

However........ once they became scrubbed in, I honestly cannot fault them. Once heated up I literally struggle to get ESP coming on when giving the throttle the full beans exiting a corner/midway through a corner, they just have loads of grip! The same can be said for accelerating from a standstill. But...I cannot compare to the PS2's, as I only had the Exalto's on before.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 12:39
My Michelin Pilot Primacy's are pretty good, an have read that the Michelin Pilot Sports are good too. Costco (if you are a member or know someone who is) are doing the Pilot Sports for £116 each.

Pilot Primacys are NOT suited to the GTI, or any hot hatch or performance car.  They are specifically designed for large luxury limos, such as the Merc E and S classes, Audi A8, VW Phaeton, etc.

Oh man, really? These are what came with the car from the dealership. It was a brand new factory build. I'm going to change them as soon as I have the cash. Cheers for the heads up T_T. Always appreciate the advice you give.  :smiley:

Are you sure that someone at the stealers didn't swap them?  Because I have never heard of any GTIs/Ed30/R32s leaving the factory with Primacys on them?  Does the age code on the tyre match the actual build date of the car?

Anyway - Primacy: http://www.michelin.co.uk/michelinuk/en/auto-utilitaires/avantages/20070312100251.html

Mich Pilot Exalto PE2 (which is the "starting point" tyre for hot hatches): http://www.michelin.co.uk/uk/front/affich.jsp?codeRubrique=20060301144538

And PS2 which is the daddy: http://www.michelin.co.uk/uk/front/affich.jsp?codeRubrique=20060215151339

Ohhh - I've just noticed that Michelin web team have listened to and acted upon my recent criticism! :afro:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Peskarik on 30 September 2008, 12:42


Which type of Michelin?  If they are the Pilot Exalto PE2, then the Pilot Sport PE2 would be considerably better....



TT, what is wrong with Exalto? I have them  :undecided:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 12:57
Ben defintly go for the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric one of the best tyres if not the best and i'm used Michelin Sport cups !

But the Mich Pilot Sport Cups are a semi-slick tyre, and are NOT suitable for everyday road use.  Have a prang on the road, with the slightest amount of wet ("mildly moist" in TopGear speak), and you will probably be prosecuted by the old bill, and your insurance will be invalid.

And there is massive criticism, along with equal dollops of praise for the Eagle F1 Asymmetrics - so whilst they may be good, they also have some serious flaws, which Goodyear themselves have been advised of!  I really don't know how peeps can recommend a product which is known to have faults.

Failing that get Michelin PS2's or the Bridgestone equivalent.

Bridgestones are also poor, and these too have been complained about on this very forum for very poor grip in the wet.  The last "decent" tyre which Bridgestone made was the "S-02 Pole Position", but that has long since been discontinued, and even when it was available, was still overshadowed (but not by much) by the original directional Mich Pilot Sport.

All three of the above tyres are great in the wet/dry and give a good ride !

Sorry, but the Bridgestones are crap in the wet.  Search the forum for tyres under username "Schrodingers Cat" (or however you spell it).

Judging by the high mileage you do, semi slicks out of the eqaution ??  ie Michelin Pilot Sport Cups / Toyo T1 R s ?

I'm sorry, but that is blatantly stupid, and completely irresponsible advice.  You should NEVER recommend using semi slick tyres for normal road use.  Even the tyre manufacturers themselves specifically state they should not be used on normal roads, with some serious disclaimer like - "you should be a professionally trained driver, fully familiar with racing style tyres, and be very prepared for a lack of grip in wet or cold conditions".  These should only be used on production-based race cars, or on road-going cars when used on track days and the like
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 13:06
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little,

On the side wall of your tyre you will have a bit that says something like this "Traction A,  Temperature A, Treadwear 280.  What is the number you have on the treadwear?  Im not sure on the scale that its is based but im pretty sure that the lower the number the softer the compound.  For example the Toyo 888's are 100 and my Conti 3's are 280

To be honest i cant complain about the conti 3's that i have although i have not had any other tyre fitted to the GTI as yet so this is a somewhat flawed opinion
Just checked the Treadwear 240 Traction A Temp A.. Not sure what that means though... :huh:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 13:08


Which type of Michelin?  If they are the Pilot Exalto PE2, then the Pilot Sport PE2 would be considerably better....



TT, what is wrong with Exalto? I have them  :undecided:

I think you mis-understood me.  There is nothing wrong with the Exaltos.  In fact, they are a very good tyre.  However, they are not an "out and out" sports performance tyre.  The Exaltos are aimed at hot hatches, cabrios and the like, and combine the abilities of sporting handling (but not extreme sports grip), with really superb wet weather performance, excellent tyre life, good comfort, and a general all-round tyre.  So you can have fun in the twisites one moment, and the next, your Granny wont be moaning because the tyre is creating a hard ride.

The Pilot Sport PS2 is just a more extreme sports performance tyre - at home on Porsche 911s, BMW M3s and M5s, Audi RS models, and Merc AMG models.  They are actually more suited to much heavier cars than the GTI, but they still work exceptionally well on the GTI too.  Though 18" is the minium rim size for the PS2, so for standard GTIs on 17" Monzas, then they would have to stick with the Exaltos.

HTH

Got a funeral to go to shortly, so I'm outa here in a minute.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 30 September 2008, 13:09
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little,

On the side wall of your tyre you will have a bit that says something like this "Traction A,  Temperature A, Treadwear 280.  What is the number you have on the treadwear?  Im not sure on the scale that its is based but im pretty sure that the lower the number the softer the compound.  For example the Toyo 888's are 100 and my Conti 3's are 280

To be honest i cant complain about the conti 3's that i have although i have not had any other tyre fitted to the GTI as yet so this is a somewhat flawed opinion
Just checked the Treadwear 240 Traction A Temp A.. Not sure what that means though... :huh:

But what TYPE of Michelins are they?  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: R32UK on 30 September 2008, 13:12
Eagle F1's here and very happy with them :smiley:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 30 September 2008, 13:17
The Michelins that are on at the min, must be made from tungstun carbide or something, as they seem to wear very little,

On the side wall of your tyre you will have a bit that says something like this "Traction A,  Temperature A, Treadwear 280.  What is the number you have on the treadwear?  Im not sure on the scale that its is based but im pretty sure that the lower the number the softer the compound.  For example the Toyo 888's are 100 and my Conti 3's are 280

To be honest i cant complain about the conti 3's that i have although i have not had any other tyre fitted to the GTI as yet so this is a somewhat flawed opinion
Just checked the Treadwear 240 Traction A Temp A.. Not sure what that means though... :huh:

But what TYPE of Michelins are they?  :rolleyes:
Sorry mate, thought I put Exaltos on there, but obviously didn't..  :grin:
Before you shoot bud, what would you recommend for my car then. Considering it's running over 300bhp and I do a bit of 1/4 mile sprinting, so woud like some decent grip..   :wink:
On the other hand, I do quite a bit of motorway miles and need them to crack 10k minimum really.. (These have easily cracker 15k with a bit to spare..
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: topher on 30 September 2008, 13:21
Liking my p-zero rosso's at the moment, but done less than 1000 miles on them so time will tell. Road noise is the only downside I've found so far.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Egbutt Wash on 30 September 2008, 13:46
Read AutoExpress.  They tested 200 tyres on a Gti and GT 225/45/17.  The edition came out a few weeks ago.  It's also here...

http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/products/total_tyre_guide/212628/the_total_tyre_guide.html
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: luca on 30 September 2008, 13:50
Doesn't matter to much on cost (within reason), as I don't pay..  :laugh:

Did you say you have Conti's on yours now Luca?

Yes i have conti sport 2's. Dont think they are very good tbh, grip is good in wet and dry but could be better.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: sixpot on 30 September 2008, 13:53
Read AutoExpress.  They tested 200 tyres on a Gti and GT 225/45/17.  The edition came out a few weeks ago.  It's also here...

http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/products/total_tyre_guide/212628/the_total_tyre_guide.html

That is last years test there Egbert, they haven't put this years online yet, which Pirelli came out on top incidentally.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Peskarik on 30 September 2008, 13:57


Which type of Michelin?  If they are the Pilot Exalto PE2, then the Pilot Sport PE2 would be considerably better....



TT, what is wrong with Exalto? I have them  :undecided:

I think you mis-understood me.  There is nothing wrong with the Exaltos.  In fact, they are a very good tyre.  However, they are not an "out and out" sports performance tyre.  The Exaltos are aimed at hot hatches, cabrios and the like, and combine the abilities of sporting handling (but not extreme sports grip), with really superb wet weather performance, excellent tyre life, good comfort, and a general all-round tyre.  So you can have fun in the twisites one moment, and the next, your Granny wont be moaning because the tyre is creating a hard ride.


Oh, allrighty then.
I can concur that in wet conditions Exaltos are very good. I've driven 120-140kph in rain - no severe hydroplaning (tyres already done 21000km).
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: bobotheclown on 30 September 2008, 13:59
wow the tyre I got with my GTI came in 4th in the test results.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: sixpot on 30 September 2008, 14:02
wow the tyre I got with my GTI came in 4th in the test results.

The test Mr Nosh posted up is for 16" tyres though and is from last year!
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Egbutt Wash on 30 September 2008, 14:46
My Bridgestone 050's are wearing out at an alarming rate.  I suspect they won't last 8000 miles, and one burst it's sidewall after hittng a little stone.  Another brand next time.

I thought the tyre link seemed a little odd, with a chunky Passat trundling round.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Egbutt Wash on 30 September 2008, 14:49
Robsaboy123 has typed out this years results for the Mkiv forum...

Dry Handling: Pirelli P Zero, Michelin Pilot Sport PS2, BF Goodrich G-force Profiler

Wet Handling: Pirelli P Zero, Continental Conti Sport Contact 3, Goodyear Egle A1 Aysmmetric

Dry Braking: Michelin Pilot Sport PS2, Pirelli P Zero, BF Goodrich G-force Profiler

Wet Braking: Goodyear Egle A1 Aysmmetric, Vredestein Ultrac-Sessanta

Aquaplaning - Straight: Uniroyal Rainsport 2,Vredestein Ultrac-Sessanta, Pirelli P Zero

Aquaplaning - curved: Pirelli P Zero, Continental Conti Sport Contact, Vredestein Ultrac-Sessanta

Thanks Rob
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: mad man gti on 30 September 2008, 17:12
I have just put the same on as when new dunlops sport maxx. Only done 15k on the old ones i did not think that was to bad.... But the price was even better 18s 225 40 £82+ vat compered with £125+ from my stealers. had goodyears on my old car and they were good.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: bobotheclown on 30 September 2008, 18:59
My Michelin Pilot Primacy's are pretty good, an have read that the Michelin Pilot Sports are good too. Costco (if you are a member or know someone who is) are doing the Pilot Sports for £116 each.

Pilot Primacys are NOT suited to the GTI, or any hot hatch or performance car.  They are specifically designed for large luxury limos, such as the Merc E and S classes, Audi A8, VW Phaeton, etc.

Oh man, really? These are what came with the car from the dealership. It was a brand new factory build. I'm going to change them as soon as I have the cash. Cheers for the heads up T_T. Always appreciate the advice you give.  :smiley:

Are you sure that someone at the stealers didn't swap them?  Because I have never heard of any GTIs/Ed30/R32s leaving the factory with Primacys on them?  Does the age code on the tyre match the actual build date of the car?

Anyway - Primacy: http://www.michelin.co.uk/michelinuk/en/auto-utilitaires/avantages/20070312100251.html

Mich Pilot Exalto PE2 (which is the "starting point" tyre for hot hatches): http://www.michelin.co.uk/uk/front/affich.jsp?codeRubrique=20060301144538

And PS2 which is the daddy: http://www.michelin.co.uk/uk/front/affich.jsp?codeRubrique=20060215151339

Ohhh - I've just noticed that Michelin web team have listened to and acted upon my recent criticism! :afro:

Hiya, got back home and checked the age code on the tyres and the were made 20th week of 2008. I picked the car up from the stealers on 21st June. Not surre what all that means but they are definitely Michelin Primacy's. I have 17" alloys and my spare 17" has Michelin Pilot Sport on it which I got from Costco.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Merlin on 30 September 2008, 21:12
Goodyear Eagle F1 GSD3's - loads better than the conti OEMs. Micheldever Tyres Nr Winchester, Cheep as chips!
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Hurdy on 30 September 2008, 23:21
I've just changed mine from Conti 2's to Conti 3's. The Conti 2's lasted just under 9K of hard motoring, very little motorway use and mainly fast A and B roads, plus a track day and around 4 or 5 1/4 mile sessions, so I'd say they did fairly well to last that distance.

The Conti 3's are just recovering from being roughed up at Bruntingthorpe after I got unlimited runs for the weekend :lipsrsealed:

Grip in the wet is excellent, but in the dry I think they could be bettered. :smiley:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 10:11
Liking my p-zero rosso's at the moment, but done less than 1000 miles on them so time will tell. Road noise is the only downside I've found so far.

On what car?

There are many "fan-boys" of Pirellis, but they are usually on much lighter cars, such as Saxos, Corsas, Ibizas, etc.  They have obviously been considerably "over tyred", and certainly don't place the tyre under anywhere near the same amount of stress as a heavier car would, such as an RS4 or RS6 - and RS owners have seriously slated the factory fit P-Zero Rossos.  One owner had a massive flap rip out of the sidewall on a minor pot hole at relatively slow speed, and I had horrendous problems with them on mine which forced me to change all four after just 4000 miles.  I would never recommend any Pirelli tyre, because they all have very weak carcasses, which do make them fairly light, but have a serious and potentially lethal side effect.  :sick:  :angry:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: luca on 01 October 2008, 10:13
I've just changed mine from Conti 2's to Conti 3's. The Conti 2's lasted just under 9K of hard motoring, very little motorway use and mainly fast A and B roads, plus a track day and around 4 or 5 1/4 mile sessions, so I'd say they did fairly well to last that distance.

The Conti 3's are just recovering from being roughed up at Bruntingthorpe after I got unlimited runs for the weekend :lipsrsealed:

Grip in the wet is excellent, but in the dry I think they could be bettered. :smiley:

Hurdy i have conti 2's at the minute. Are the conti 3's loads better?
Would you buy conti 3's again?
Thanks
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 10:28
Read AutoExpress.  They tested 200 tyres on a Gti and GT 225/45/17.  The edition came out a few weeks ago.  It's also here...

http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/products/total_tyre_guide/212628/the_total_tyre_guide.html

And please explain how the scorching environmental conditions of Rome compare to chilly old Blighty.

And how these tyres are specific to a hot hatch?  They are not!  They are actually for a family car, or even a luxury car, which places very, very different requirements, and expectations on a tyre!  :smug:

And the fact that they completely failed "up front" to detail the exact specification of each tyre being used is typical of the way journos distort their reports.  :sick:

Finally, regarding the wet tests, they only tested brand new tyres - as tyres wear down, they can dramatically alter their wet weather ability - what may get the highest wet performance rating when brand new, may very well be dramatically overshadowed by others as the tread is say half worn.  This is the classic problem with the Dunlop SportMaxx - when brand new, its aquaplaning resistance isn't too bad, but when you get down to 5mm of tread remaining, they dramatically start to aquaplane.  This is caused by "strengthening ribs" in the tread pattern blocking the outer channels.  Michelin are well known to be one of the most consistent wet weather performers, even as the tread wears to the legal limit.  :nerd:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: winrya on 01 October 2008, 10:34
I've had conti 2's, goodyear f1 gsd3's and im running on f1 assymetricals at the moment.  The contis were awful, GSD3's were brilliant until half worn where they became noisy and awful in the wet.  The assymetricals I've had on the front for the past 6k and they have transformed the car.  The ride is more supple, handling is more adjustable and i can floor it in 1st and 2nd and not have to worry about traction (even in the damp)

I had another 2 put on the rear yesterday to replace the contis which have done 30k and the car feels so much smoother.  Those mid corner bumps seem to have gone, but the biggest difference i noticed yesteday on a 100 mile trip is that there is almost no road noise.  It's amazing how much difference there is between tyres.  I would never consider anything but F1's :cool:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 10:47
Hiya, got back home and checked the age code on the tyres and the were made 20th week of 2008. I picked the car up from the stealers on 21st June.

OK, that means your tyres were manufactured week commencing 12 May 08, and you picked up your car 5 weeks later!  :undecided:  Any reason to delay the collection of your car from the stealers (maybe you were away on hols, or wanted to wait for a birthday or sommat)?  :huh:  If you want to PM me your VIN, I will be able to tell you the exact day your car came off the production line.  This will go some way to confirm if your tyres have been swapped, as VW (just like all the major manufactures) will factory fit tyres from the same or previous week as the car is rolling along the line.  I reckon that a Passat supplied by your stealer has your tyres on it!  :rolleyes:  Do your alloys have the factory wheel balance weights, or the dealer balance weights?  Post a picture if you aint sure.  :smiley:

Not surre what all that means but they are definitely Michelin Primacy's. I have 17" alloys and my spare 17" has Michelin Pilot Sport on it which I got from Costco.

What, you got an additional full size spare?  :huh:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 10:49
Goodyear Eagle F1 GSD3's - loads better than the conti OEMs.

But they are directional tyres, and 1980s technology.  :rolleyes:  Why do you think that even Goodyear have caught up with modern technology, by ditching the GSD3s for their latest Eagle F1 Asymmetrics?
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 10:59
I've had conti 2's, goodyear f1 gsd3's and im running on f1 assymetricals at the moment.  The contis were awful, GSD3's were brilliant until half worn where they became noisy and awful in the wet.

And that is the classic reason why directional tyres are useless, and explains why Goodyear, a long time "champion" of directional tyres were forced to ditch their old skool technology for the modern asymmetric design.

I would never consider anything but F1's :cool:

But you have never run on Mich PS2s.  On the RS forums, many peeps compare Goodyear, Conti and Michelin - the vast majority select the PS2 as being the top of the crop.

And if the Goodyear F1s where such a good tyre as the Goodyear fans would have you believe, why dont Porsche fit them?  Porsche are a no nonsence, no compromise out and out high performance sports car manufacturer, and if these Goodyears did perform better than the Contis or PS2s, you can be absolutely certain that Porsche would factory fit them!  :smug:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 11:05
Sorry mate, thought I put Exaltos on there, but obviously didn't..  :grin:
Before you shoot bud, what would you recommend for my car then. Considering it's running over 300bhp and I do a bit of 1/4 mile sprinting, so woud like some decent grip..   :wink:

Michelin Pilot Sport PS2.  :smiley:

Or if you have some track-only rims, and just for the 1/4 mile'ers, then some semi-slick Michelin Pilot Sport Cups.  A set of tyre warmers would also be handy in chilly Blighty!  :wink:  :grin:

On the other hand, I do quite a bit of motorway miles and need them to crack 10k minimum really.. (These have easily cracker 15k with a bit to spare..

Well, to be honest, if your Exaltos have reached 15k miles with all the above, then providing you don't start driving like a continual loon, then the PS2s should crack the 10k mark.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: luca on 01 October 2008, 11:23
TT how much are the ps2 in 225/40 18?
Do you think the pilot sport cups are as good as toyo r888?
Never used a semi slick tyre so no idea which to go for. Will only use them on trackdays, drag strip, very hot days etc.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 12:43
TT how much are the ps2 in 225/40 18?

Lazy fecker . . . .

Try www.BlackCircles.co.uk, www.MyTyres.co.uk, or www.pneus-online.co.uk - and then ring around your locals, quoting the cheapest online price, and ask them to price match.  A word of warning, avoid ThikFit like a woman with a scabby fanny!

Do you think the pilot sport cups are as good as toyo r888?
Never used a semi slick tyre so no idea which to go for. Will only use them on trackdays, drag strip, very hot days etc.

Semis arn't my thang.  Ooo errrr.  And how the fcuk did James Blunt get away with braggin about havin a "semi by the sea" - perv!?   :evil:

All I will say is that you will get massively better customer service from Michelin than you would do from any of the other tyre manufactures - been there, done than and got the t-shirt.  :wink:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Vtec Abuser on 01 October 2008, 13:04
Sorry mate, thought I put Exaltos on there, but obviously didn't..  :grin:
Before you shoot bud, what would you recommend for my car then. Considering it's running over 300bhp and I do a bit of 1/4 mile sprinting, so woud like some decent grip..   :wink:

Michelin Pilot Sport PS2.  :smiley:

Or if you have some track-only rims, and just for the 1/4 mile'ers, then some semi-slick Michelin Pilot Sport Cups.  A set of tyre warmers would also be handy in chilly Blighty!  :wink:  :grin:

On the other hand, I do quite a bit of motorway miles and need them to crack 10k minimum really.. (These have easily cracker 15k with a bit to spare..

Well, to be honest, if your Exaltos have reached 15k miles with all the above, then providing you don't start driving like a continual loon, then the PS2s should crack the 10k mark.
Are the PS2's a softer compound then mate?
I shall not be changing wheels/tyres for 1/4 mile racing. Just run it as the car stands and can't really be arsed with buying another set of rims for just that.. So they need to be a sticky tyre that doesn't lose 2mm of tread after every emergency start..  :wink:
Looks like i'm stuck between..
PS2's
Conti Sport 3's
and F1 Ass's..
Mmmmm, will see what the leasing company say I suppose..
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: E30M3 on 01 October 2008, 13:06
I understand where you are coming from Teutonic T, semi slicks as everyday tyres is a bit excessive but i've used the Sport cups all year around for about 3/4 years !!!

They were great in the wet, you get much more feedback about what the road condition is like, the only time they are dangerous is when you hit a patch of standing water/ice but you should be looking at the road in the first place !!!

You are also correct T_T that it would require slightly more skill to use the tyres as they can be pushed very far , but when they do give up grip its almost unexpected / very quick to do so.

I am a firm believer the best mod anyone can do to a car is to increase their driving skill/safety/quality, going on car course / driver training days .

  Even in the pouring rain T_T the cups are an awesome tyre, true you will not be pushing that hard but the tyres make the driving experince much better and in the dry the grip they give is astonishing .

I've noticed everytime i have to use the normal road tyres, some of the feel and handling has gone.

Bad points of the semi slicks is Cost,ride(stiff sidewall), road noise, tyre life (be lucky to get 4000 miles!), handling standing water and the breakaway of the tyre.

Also what the car manufactures do not tell you is that for cups to work effectively there has to be more than -2.5 camber (too excessive for some as said for everday use) ! ! ! ! that means you end up with the tyres burning up the inner edges .



Toyo R888's are cheaper than Cups for a reason, they do not provide more grip or feel than the cups.

I really do think that the Goodyear Eagle Asymetrics are a better tyre than the Michelin PS2, especially in the wet and on tyre life, especially when you bring in tyre costs !

The PS2 also wear very quickly under hard use  ! the Goodyear is very good in that manner !

Ben do the Goodyear Asymmetric , they are what you are looking for !



Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Hurdy on 01 October 2008, 15:37
I've just changed mine from Conti 2's to Conti 3's. The Conti 2's lasted just under 9K of hard motoring, very little motorway use and mainly fast A and B roads, plus a track day and around 4 or 5 1/4 mile sessions, so I'd say they did fairly well to last that distance.

The Conti 3's are just recovering from being roughed up at Bruntingthorpe after I got unlimited runs for the weekend :lipsrsealed:

Grip in the wet is excellent, but in the dry I think they could be bettered. :smiley:

Hurdy i have conti 2's at the minute. Are the conti 3's loads better?
Would you buy conti 3's again?
Thanks

I'd have the Michelins if I was paying for them, b ut I have a full service maintenance and tyre package and they OEM Conti's are included. :smiley:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 16:32
Sorry mate, thought I put Exaltos on there, but obviously didn't..  :grin:
Before you shoot bud, what would you recommend for my car then. Considering it's running over 300bhp and I do a bit of 1/4 mile sprinting, so woud like some decent grip..   :wink:

Michelin Pilot Sport PS2.  :smiley:

Or if you have some track-only rims, and just for the 1/4 mile'ers, then some semi-slick Michelin Pilot Sport Cups.  A set of tyre warmers would also be handy in chilly Blighty!  :wink:  :grin:

On the other hand, I do quite a bit of motorway miles and need them to crack 10k minimum really.. (These have easily cracker 15k with a bit to spare..

Well, to be honest, if your Exaltos have reached 15k miles with all the above, then providing you don't start driving like a continual loon, then the PS2s should crack the 10k mark.
Are the PS2's a softer compound then mate?

Yup, softer compound than the Exaltos, but with a stiffer carcass.  Actually, to be pedantic, they are dual compound rubber, meaning they are quite hard rubber on the outer, and softer rubber on the inner.

I shall not be changing wheels/tyres for 1/4 mile racing. Just run it as the car stands and can't really be arsed with buying another set of rims for just that.. So they need to be a sticky tyre that doesn't lose 2mm of tread after every emergency start..  :wink:
Looks like i'm stuck between..
PS2's
Conti Sport 3's
and F1 Ass's..
Mmmmm, will see what the leasing company say I suppose..

PS2s would still get my vote out of that lot, and that would be also the same POV on the Audi RS forums.

And if the lease company are paying - bonus.  But if they don't, just offer to pay the difference.  :wink:  Whatever you do, just be absolutely certain that they only fit the "Extra Load" tyres, as there are some shady/incompetant tw@ts who will just fit the standard load tyres.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 17:09
I understand where you are coming from Teutonic T, semi slicks as everyday tyres is a bit excessive but i've used the Sport cups all year around for about 3/4 years !!!

But they should never be recommended as a "first choice" to a new user, on the road or the track.  :wink:  That is the real crux of my concern.  :smiley:

They were great in the wet, you get much more feedback about what the road condition is like, the only time they are dangerous is when you hit a patch of standing water/ice but you should be looking at the road in the first place !!!

I agree you should be looking where you are going, but sometimes, it is absolutley impossible to avoid standing water.  And that is where the danger for road use stems from, not only for your own car, but dangerous for other road users too!  :rolleyes:

You are also correct T_T that it would require slightly more skill to use the tyres as they can be pushed very far , but when they do give up grip its almost unexpected / very quick to do so.

Agreed, and the limits of available grip are considerably greater than normal road tyres.  However, the brakaway point is very sudden, with very little warning - so one moment you are leaning extremely hard on your tyres round a corner, and then the slightest requirement to change the steering angle WILL mean an extremely rapid trip to the hedge/ditch/lamp post/dry stone wall.  That is one of the absolute crucial issues with semi slicks (and race tyres in general) - with Michelins being both the best (in terms of outright grip), but also the worst (in terms of sudden brakaway).

I am a firm believer the best mod anyone can do to a car is to increase their driving skill/safety/quality, going on car course / driver training days .

I agree, but that is a completely different issue.  :smiley:

Even in the pouring rain T_T the cups are an awesome tyre, true you will not be pushing that hard but the tyres make the driving experince much better and in the dry the grip they give is astonishing .

But that is the BIG problem with semis, especially as it has a propensity to rain here in blighty!  If it were DubaiPhil, or any of our South African or Aussie friends, I wouldn't have any real problems with recommending semis.

With PS2s, I can push my car as hard as I like, wet or dry.  And in my RS4, I can use all 420 ponies to their max, even in 1st gear in the wet without any loss of traction.  So the PS2s really are a no compromise tyre, unlike say the P-Zero Rosso, Dunlop ShyteMaxx, or even the ContiSportContact2s

I've noticed everytime i have to use the normal road tyres, some of the feel and handling has gone.

But that is only because you have "acclimatised" yourself to the semis.  It is no difference to the Mk2 and Mk5 owners, who report that their Mk2s have crap brakes when compared to those of the Mk5.

Bad points of the semi slicks is Cost,ride(stiff sidewall), road noise, tyre life (be lucky to get 4000 miles!), handling standing water and the breakaway of the tyre.

I'm surprised you report they are noisey!  With such a "little" tread pattern, they should be much quieter!  :undecided:

Low tyre life is to be fully expected of race-type tyres, as is the lack of coping with standing water and rapid breakaway.

Also what the car manufactures do not tell you is that for cups to work effectively there has to be more than -2.5 camber (too excessive for some as said for everday use) ! ! ! ! that means you end up with the tyres burning up the inner edges .

Ahh, but the reason for the excessive camber is to ensure that the tyres heat up adequately.  :nerd:  If they arn't able to reach their correct operating temperature, then they wont offer the full amount of grip.  :smug:

But that amount of camber when used on normal road tyres will improve cornering handling no end too - but the tyres wont last very long!  :wink:

Toyo R888's are cheaper than Cups for a reason, they do not provide more grip or feel than the cups.

Never really rated any Toyo, and nor Yokohamas either.

I really do think that the Goodyear Eagle Asymetrics are a better tyre than the Michelin PS2, especially in the wet and on tyre life, especially when you bring in tyre costs !

But costs should never really be an issue when buying tyres.  You should by the best tyres, irrespective of costs.  If buying Michelins really does blow your piggy bank, then instead of using V-Power/Tesco99, just fill up with standard unleaded for a couple of tankfulls, because the benefits of quality tyres will far outweigh their costs over the longer term.

And I can't agree with the wet weather issue, where Michelin are well known to be supreme in wet weather conditions.

Don't forget, Goodyear are an American company, and their tyres, or should that be "tires"  :wink:, are designed for use on American spec tarmac (which is different from many European black tops), and for American weather patterns.  Michelin and Continental are both European (French and German), and are specifically designed for European weather patterns, temperatures, and road surfaces.

The PS2 also wear very quickly under hard use  ! the Goodyear is very good in that manner !

Can't agree.  Peeps on the Audi RS forums repeatedly state that the PS2 lasts longer than the F1.  The PS2s do wear slightly quicker than the CSC2, and are about on a par with the CSC3.

Ben do the Goodyear Asymmetric , they are what you are looking for !

PS2, PS2, PS2  :grin:  :grin:  :grin:  :grin:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Teutonic_Tamer on 01 October 2008, 17:10
I've just changed mine from Conti 2's to Conti 3's. The Conti 2's lasted just under 9K of hard motoring, very little motorway use and mainly fast A and B roads, plus a track day and around 4 or 5 1/4 mile sessions, so I'd say they did fairly well to last that distance.

The Conti 3's are just recovering from being roughed up at Bruntingthorpe after I got unlimited runs for the weekend :lipsrsealed:

Grip in the wet is excellent, but in the dry I think they could be bettered. :smiley:

Hurdy i have conti 2's at the minute. Are the conti 3's loads better?
Would you buy conti 3's again?
Thanks

I'd have the Michelins if I was paying for them, b ut I have a full service maintenance and tyre package and they OEM Conti's are included. :smiley:

Can't you offer to make up the cost difference?  :wink:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Hurdy on 01 October 2008, 17:19
I've just changed mine from Conti 2's to Conti 3's. The Conti 2's lasted just under 9K of hard motoring, very little motorway use and mainly fast A and B roads, plus a track day and around 4 or 5 1/4 mile sessions, so I'd say they did fairly well to last that distance.

The Conti 3's are just recovering from being roughed up at Bruntingthorpe after I got unlimited runs for the weekend :lipsrsealed:

Grip in the wet is excellent, but in the dry I think they could be bettered. :smiley:

Hurdy i have conti 2's at the minute. Are the conti 3's loads better?
Would you buy conti 3's again?
Thanks

I'd have the Michelins if I was paying for them, b ut I have a full service maintenance and tyre package and they OEM Conti's are included. :smiley:

Can't you offer to make up the cost difference?  :wink:

Yes, but I thought I'd give the Conti 3's a chance first :smiley:

TBH the grip in the dry seems to be worse than the Conti 2's :undecided:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: E30M3 on 01 October 2008, 18:00
As usual Teutonic_Tamer (Sean) i am gobsmacked by your knowledge ! :cool:

You put some BIG tuners to shame with your knowledge and intelligence   :smiley:

I never knew the reason why camber was needed for the cups other than the contact patch under load/ conering !!! and that was told to me by a suppossed BIG BMW tuning firm !!!

You are right never ever be economical with tyres , those are the things that keep us safe !!!

Why is there no Bow smilie for Sean !!!!  :grin:   (http://tbn0.google.com/images?q=tbn:86BC5hX-6sBPeM:http://www.msn-winks.ws/files/bow.jpg)


Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Stiggy on 01 October 2008, 23:18
I'm actually in the process of changing my tyres - gone for eagle f1 assymetrics, coming from conti 2s.  They're going to be fitted tomorrow (all fours) - will report back if you like.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: winrya on 02 October 2008, 00:09

I would never consider anything but F1's :cool:

But you have never run on Mich PS2s.  On the RS forums, many peeps compare Goodyear, Conti and Michelin - the vast majority select the PS2 as being the top of the crop.

And if the Goodyear F1s where such a good tyre as the Goodyear fans would have you believe, why dont Porsche fit them?  Porsche are a no nonsence, no compromise out and out high performance sports car manufacturer, and if these Goodyears did perform better than the Contis or PS2s, you can be absolutely certain that Porsche would factory fit them!  :smug:
[/quote]

I had them on a previous car.  I found them expensive, average in the wet and scary in low temperatures (frost/snow)  I remember one time not being able to reverse off my drive downhill.  I changed to gds3's quickly after which sorted my problems :cool:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: R32UK on 02 October 2008, 08:55
I have run on both... and would say its hard to choose between the 2! The PS2's were on a much lighter and more nible car and were a fantastic tyre. The F1's have transformed the .:R but it is much much heavier than my previous car and has the benifit of 4WD. I cant knock the PS2's at all and so far the F1's have been great but only really compared against Dunflop sport maxx.. which were not so great.

Still have the Dunflops on the back and have noticed the back twitching out on a few occasions when the fronts (F1's) stay planted. think this shows the gap between the two :nerd:
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: bobotheclown on 02 October 2008, 09:42
Hiya, got back home and checked the age code on the tyres and the were made 20th week of 2008. I picked the car up from the stealers on 21st June.

OK, that means your tyres were manufactured week commencing 12 May 08, and you picked up your car 5 weeks later!  :undecided:  Any reason to delay the collection of your car from the stealers (maybe you were away on hols, or wanted to wait for a birthday or sommat)?  :huh:  If you want to PM me your VIN, I will be able to tell you the exact day your car came off the production line.  This will go some way to confirm if your tyres have been swapped, as VW (just like all the major manufactures) will factory fit tyres from the same or previous week as the car is rolling along the line.  I reckon that a Passat supplied by your stealer has your tyres on it!  :rolleyes:  Do your alloys have the factory wheel balance weights, or the dealer balance weights?  Post a picture if you aint sure.  :smiley:

Not surre what all that means but they are definitely Michelin Primacy's. I have 17" alloys and my spare 17" has Michelin Pilot Sport on it which I got from Costco.

What, you got an additional full size spare?  :huh:

Yup got a 17" Monza/Detroit alloy as a spare wheel and a boot conversion thing from VW dealer so that the boot floor is flat. Much prefer a full size spare wheel compared to those skinny space savers. the dealer phoned me up on Wed 18th June and I went a collected it on the Saturday.

I was wondering if it was a real issue have Primacy's on a GTI? So far I haven't really pushed the car.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: Egbutt Wash on 02 October 2008, 11:45
Now the nights are closing in might I suggest an eye test.  Good vision will allow you to travel faster, in greater safety and at night far more than super unleaded or the marginal difference between brands of tyre.  Just buy a decent brand, keep them pumped up and stop worrying.
Title: Re: New Tyres time.. Suggestions please???
Post by: sixpot on 02 October 2008, 12:56
Now the nights are closing in might I suggest an eye test.  Good vision will allow you to travel faster, in greater safety and at night far more than super unleaded or the marginal difference between brands of tyre.  Just buy a decent brand, keep them pumped up and stop worrying.

Good advice there Mr Nosh, its all down to individual choice at the end of the day.