GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk4 => Topic started by: baz-vegas on 16 November 2007, 16:11

Title: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: baz-vegas on 16 November 2007, 16:11
Hi everyone. :cool:

I have 4000 quid to spend on a golf. :grin: At the mo, i am wanting a MK4 1.8 GTI Turbo. Have asked many people what they think, and half say spend it on a MK3. What do you all think. I just like the look of the MK4. And its a TURBO.
This will be my first golf, and cant wait as i have had a punto and a corsa. So its time to see what all the rage is about.

I live in east London and have been quoted 770 full comp from esure on a V reg 1.8 GTI T. Is this good as i am 28.

Please help me pick. The money is just sitting here! :wink:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: Marco Rossi on 16 November 2007, 16:18
Get the Turbo!!

just my opinion mind.
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: Britman on 16 November 2007, 18:33
if you can afford it get the mk4 !!! you will regret getting a mk3 unless its mint. I feel the mk4 is so much nicer to drive more refined more relible, well electrics arnt much different, if i could afford a mk4 id get one as i have nothing but trouble on the 3 mk3's i have had even the good one i had, jsut my opinion though. I want a mk4 my mates ahs been problem free his v reg one and is much nicer
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: AlanD on 16 November 2007, 19:04
This is just my opinion.

If I was going to get a MK4 (which I have lol). I'd save up another 1k and spend 5k on a nice, decent, tidy lower mileage one.

If you can afford it, get the MK4.

(You might be better off asking this in the VW related section as I cant see anyone in this section saying "Yeah, get the MK3" ! lol)
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: Britman on 16 November 2007, 19:10
^^^ i did
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: jamadz on 16 November 2007, 19:31
mk4 and then remap it :) much more fun!
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: AlanD on 16 November 2007, 20:01
^^^ i did

No, you said get the MK4, or am I missing something?
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: richw911 on 16 November 2007, 20:02
It has got to be the 1.8T :grin:  and you NEED a remap  :grin: You will not be disappointed  :laugh:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: baz-vegas on 16 November 2007, 20:25
Nice 1 guys for all the replies. I think it will have to be the MK4 then.
Not too sure if i can afford another 1k, maybe an extra 500 at a push.

Thanks again, will keep you all informed. :cool:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: AlanD on 17 November 2007, 01:15
Good luck.

Post some of the cars you intend to look at on here.
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: BobbyT on 17 November 2007, 07:45
depends what you want, i love the bora 1.8t but i prefer the vr due to the sound it makes!! with that cash you could get a mint tuned vr! get it supercharged for £1500 quid and then you have 260-300 bhp to play with!  :grin:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: AlanD on 17 November 2007, 09:54
If its costing him £770 for a fully comp 1.8T he will probably have to remorgage the house to get insured on a supercharger VR6.
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: countcdw on 17 November 2007, 15:14
I recently sold my modded VR in favour of buying my mums 1.8T as it is one owner and only 50k from new. Now I really wish I still had my VR  :cry:

Guess its just a personal choice, I just think the 6 sounds lovely and is a bit more raw than the later 1.8T, sure the mk4 is more refined, but I personally prefer the earlier model in terms of how it drives although the Mk4 is a nicer shape :undecided: hard choice!

(http://rides.webshots.com/photo/2564568870060725598GDNtlC?vhost=rides)
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: Hurdy on 17 November 2007, 15:42
It's a no-brainer...go for the MKIV  :cool:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: twogolfs on 18 November 2007, 13:07
You could consider the V5 Mk4, could be cheaper to buy than the 1.8T but not as tuneable.  If it doesn't have to be a Golf you'll get the 170 brake version of this engine in the Seat Toledo on a Y plate for 4K fairly easily.  Other option is the Bora.
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: DazVR6 on 18 November 2007, 14:24
Mk3 VR is has to be, screw them boxed square shaped box's they call mk4's :laugh:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: boneybradley on 18 November 2007, 15:40

screw them boxed square shaped box's they call mk4's :laugh:


 :laugh: :grin: :laugh: :grin: :laugh: :grin: :laugh: :grin: :laugh:     I will go away and hide now!!
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: gooseuk on 18 November 2007, 15:45
Its all about what you can afford. I love my mk4 so nice to drive and so reliable ( toaching wood million times now lol ).

Not driven a 1.8turbo but from what i hear there mint.

Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: BobbyT on 18 November 2007, 16:37
they need tweeking big time mind, the suspension is sooooo bad as standard!  :smiley:
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: Britman on 19 November 2007, 01:35
agreed ^^^ a set of eibachs makes a big difference with a good ride still
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: Ridg on 19 November 2007, 10:24
You could consider the V5 Mk4

you would be better off getting the 1.8T or the V6 4Mo as the V5 doesn't have enough power for its weight

Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: was_ser on 19 November 2007, 10:56
I have a MK4 GTi for driving around with the missue and a mk2 8V GTi with a very turned engine for the weekend. It seems to be the perfect setup.  :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin:

However I'v have heard that the Turbos can have a lot of problems so have a good look around before buying. 

To be honest I would go for the GT TDI and chip it. (MK4)

VR6 fast but with pertol prices????and it will have to be a highline!
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: faisalgti on 19 November 2007, 19:26
Mk3 VR is has to be, screw them boxed square shaped box's they call mk4's :laugh:


Dont you think the MK3 looks more like a box than the MK4??
Title: Re: MK4 vs MK3. Which 1?
Post by: gooseuk on 19 November 2007, 20:44
they need tweeking big time mind, the suspension is sooooo bad as standard!  :smiley:

I have a 1.9 tdi so i am guessing suspension set up is roughly same as the 1.8 t.

How much for a decent suspension setup then?