GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk2 => Topic started by: Jungle_Don on 11 November 2007, 15:10

Title: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Jungle_Don on 11 November 2007, 15:10
the golf has 90bhp and the xr2 fiesta has 96 but im gussing the golf has more tourque but weights more which is quicker?

do 1.8 non gtis feel quick at all like throw you back in the seat?
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Spawn_of_Satan_666 on 11 November 2007, 16:20
I used to have a 205 gti 1.6 (10 years ago) and my mates driver used to keep up with that.
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: takethefifth on 11 November 2007, 20:11
Ooh i fancy a punt on this.... I will say the XR2 for more horses, lot lighter and probaby a more sporting setup on gearbox (and same for suspension setup on the twistys).

No evidence for any of this but thanks for listening!  :grin:
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Philpy on 11 November 2007, 21:26
Sorry XR2 would kill it...... My mother in law had a 1.8 driver and it wasnt anything like an XR2.... They are a lot lighter.. Id even say a good XR2 would give a 8v Gti a hard time  :lipsrsealed:
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: monkeyalan on 11 November 2007, 21:30
i had a mk1 xr2 and it was pretty nippy with its 84 stonking horses.  :grin:
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Gernster on 11 November 2007, 22:26
xr2, but unless that cvh had been rebiult recently I doubt it would still have the 96 bhp :grin:

used to be into fords in a big way, worst thing about then was the bloody cvh, terrible engine........

oil pumps would struggle to last 100k, then kill the top end.
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Dan_GTI on 11 November 2007, 22:28
power to weight ratio, id say the xr2
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Philpy on 12 November 2007, 08:52
Everyone always says the CVH engine was rubbish, but surely its a better engine than the Pushrod engines that were so tappety?? Anyway I had a MK2 Fiesta 1.4s when I was 18. Ragged the guts out of it and drove like a complete tw@t for 2 years in it, Never given a car so much abuse) bought it on 78,000 and sold it on 115,000 and it was still going strong!
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Gernster on 12 November 2007, 12:03
when the oil pump goes it does the hydraulic cam followers and they sound worse than the ohv then!!
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Spawn_of_Satan_666 on 12 November 2007, 21:10
Quote from: Philpy on 11 November 2007, 21:26
Sorry XR2 would kill it...... My mother in law had a 1.8 driver and it wasnt anything like an XR2.... They are a lot lighter.. Id even say a good XR2 would give a 8v Gti a hard time  :lipsrsealed:

Are you insane!!!  :laugh: My 1.1 mk2 fiesta with a 1300 sport carb and reprofiled cam used to keep up with xr2's.
Title: Re: mk2 golf 1.8 driver vs mk2 xr2?
Post by: Philpy on 12 November 2007, 22:22
Must of been a good one then as 1.1 fiestas were dog slow... Summin like 56bhp!