GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk2 => Topic started by: oakgreengolf on 23 August 2007, 21:05

Title: funny whinning noise
Post by: oakgreengolf on 23 August 2007, 21:05
Ive got a mk2 16v golf 175k on the clock. I decided to change the cambelt, alternator belt and the waterpump. I also flushed the rad. Since putting it back together its making a whinning noise from the alternater, water pump, power steering area. I got the water pump from gscp's. The belts seem to be tight enough and are not rubbing on the covers. Has anyone got any ideas what would be causing the noise as its rather anoying. i gets louder as you rev the engine. any help greatly appreciated
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: DarnPB on 23 August 2007, 22:21
The whining noise could be a belt tensioned too tightly, or, if tensioned correctly, you have found a pulley bearing that is worn that you did not know about before. If it was the water pump bearing gone, then it is likely that the pump would leak water.
Re-check your tensions first. The cam belt tension should be so that you can twist the belt through 90 degrees with moderate force with your finger and thumb, in the middle of the pullies that are furthest apart from each other.
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: Ben Lessani on 24 August 2007, 08:23
Sounds like a belt is too tight. Sometimes you can notice by the engine running a little bit funny (poor performance) if is the timing belt. If its a purring whine - then its overtensioned belt, if its a sqeakey whine then I would guess a pulley has been incorrectly fitted - you've not put the tensioner on backwards have you?

Ben
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: oakgreengolf on 24 August 2007, 16:04
tensioner is definatly the right way round, ill recheck the powersteering and alternator belts, I may have over done them a bit. How tight should they be?.
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: DarnPB on 24 August 2007, 16:43
tensioner is definatly the right way round, ill recheck the powersteering and alternator belts, I may have over done them a bit. How tight should they be?.

Difficult to answer. Make them so that you get about 5-10mm deflection when firmly moved with finger and thumb.
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: Organisys on 24 August 2007, 16:56
whining noise is usualy narrowed down to girlfriend in passenger seat.

 :grin:
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: mattneck(Beavis) on 24 August 2007, 18:44
whining noise is usualy narrowed down to girlfriend in passenger seat.

 :grin:


10/10  :grin:
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: oakgreengolf on 24 August 2007, 20:01
Could be the girlfriend, although still makes the noise without her in it LOL. loosened the belts, doesnt seem as bad now though is still there a little bit.
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: Organisys on 25 August 2007, 12:29
My money is on the water pump bearing.
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: 8vRicey on 25 August 2007, 12:30
My money is on the water pump bearing.


Changed my pump yesterday, no more whining !!  :wink: :grin:
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: oakgreengolf on 25 August 2007, 17:17
just put a new water pump on it, are there ever any probs with them its from german sweedish car parts. dont really want to have too take it off again  :sad:

Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: 8vRicey on 25 August 2007, 17:20
just put a new water pump on it, are there ever any probs with them its from german sweedish car parts. dont really want to have too take it off again  :sad:


If it's a new pump it rules that out. Might be alternator or power steering pump ??
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: oakgreengolf on 25 August 2007, 20:59
just seems strange the noise has started since renewing the belts. perhaps its rubbing on the covers??. ill have to investigate further
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: Organisys on 25 August 2007, 21:17
My GSF water pump lasted about 5k miles!

Rubbish !
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: DarnPB on 25 August 2007, 23:00
Penny drops. Check which way you tensioned the cam belt. If it is tensioned the wrong way, it rubs against the cover. You can either take a chunk out of the cover if you don't want to disturb said belt, or do it properly and re-adjust tensioner, but the other way. :wink:
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: Jungle_Don on 25 August 2007, 23:30
had a simuar whinning noise in my old car aswelll turnd out to be the girlfriend  :laugh:
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: J.stafford16v on 25 August 2007, 23:45
Tensioner
Title: Re: funny whinning noise
Post by: T_J_G on 26 August 2007, 12:16
Could be the girlfriend, although still makes the noise without her in it LOL. loosened the belts, doesnt seem as bad now though is still there a little bit.

I suggest removing her from the boot  :tongue:

Anyway, i had that sound when i bought my GTi it sounded like it was supercharged? Whinig that got higher in pitch as the revs went upp. I foud that the cam bet tensioner was to otight. So i just untightened it a bit and the noise disapeared. I didnt otice any difference in performance when it was/wasn't whining.