GolfGTIforum.co.uk
Model specific boards => Golf mk7 => Topic started by: Gorocco on 14 May 2019, 11:28
-
Hi folks,
I have a March 2016 PP which as it stands has done just under 20K
Rear pads/discs were replaced March 2019 on last service.
Advised front need replacing - 25% wear left - Quote £319.
Is this normal wear and tear? Can't say I drive the car hard - anything but.
Am I being overly cynical? Thoughts appreciated ...
-
Common trick to get you to spend money. I'd take it to a garage you trust for a 2nd opinion.
I'm not saying they are 100% lying but my 2014PP has got 27,000 miles on it and I've yet to have any form of brake component replacement in it's whole life (apart from fluid of course).
-
Thanks Gnasher. Inclined to agree with you.
-
I have exactly the same year and mileage, same discs and pads from new.
Common trick to get you to spend money. I'd take it to a garage you trust for a 2nd opinion.
I'm not saying they are 100% lying but my 2014PP has got 27,000 miles on it and I've yet to have any form of brake component replacement in it's whole life (apart from fluid of course).
-
@Gorocco; unless you’re particularly hard on your brakes, I’d be surprised if the fronts are 75% worn after 20k miles. My Polo GTI had done around 18k miles at the last service and the garage said my front pads were approx 25% worn.
Sounds as if your dealer is short on servicing and repair work and is trying to drum up some more business to keep the workshop techs busy. Agree with Gnasher - get a second opinion from another garage.
-
Thanks SRGTD. I'm easy on the brakes. No warning lights, no noises, pedal feels fine so I'll have the car checked later in the year.
-
Euro car parts have some decent discount code occasionally on Brembo pads and discs when the time comes ..just paid 80 for a set rear discs and pads
-
Get some Brembo's for Eurorcar parts.
Probably half the price.
-
What? I replaced my GTI PP rears at 70k miles and they had 2mm left on them, the fronts have wear sensors on so you will have a few thousand after that activates, my original fronts are now on 72k. Even 25% wear left is at least 5k miles.
-
Lack of use perhaps a factor.
My 2015,s rears were advisable when I bought it ,It has only covered 12 k in 3 years, a set of Brembo pads and discs just over £100 from a quick look
-
Lack of use perhaps a factor.
My 2015,s rears were advisable when I bought it ,It has only covered 12 k in 3 years, a set of Brembo pads and discs just over £100 from a quick look
I can see where you're coming from, but this would only be a factor if the discs had corroded to the point they were still pitted etc. once the surface rust had worn off. That said, as long as they still functioned with enough power, they would still pass an MOT and the main issue would simply be appearance and a slight increase in wear rate from that point onwards.
-
Hi folks,
I have a March 2016 PP which as it stands has done just under 20K
Rear pads/discs were replaced March 2019 on last service.
Advised front need replacing - 25% wear left - Quote £319.
Is this normal wear and tear? Can't say I drive the car hard - anything but.
Am I being overly cynical? Thoughts appreciated ...
When challenged they will probably say 'Ah sorry, our mistake, only 25% worn not left!'
At less than 20k no possible way for you to have used 75% of front let alone rear unless all those miles were done purely around the Nurburgring! :grin:
-
When challenged they will probably say 'Ah sorry, our mistake, only 25% worn not left!'
At less than 20k no possible way for you to have used 75% of front let alone rear unless all those miles were done purely around the Nurburgring! :grin:
Thanks Jim,
I get videos sent while they service the vehicle.
In March 2018 i was advised to replace the rears due to corrosion so fair enough I arranged for this to happen during the March 2019 service i.e I book this to happen on the same day. I get another video during the March 2019 service prior to the car being returned telling me it will pass the MOT (being done the same time) but to be aware of the rear pads etc ! I ring up the dealer and remind them they are supposed to be replacing the rear pads etc today while it is in for servicing ! Oh yes, they say ... it will be done ... and was also advised I need new wipers (at £37) to get it through the MOT. I paid for brake flush on top of the service and I was also offered an engine flush which I politely declined.
A few days before, I had an absolute nightmare organising an extended service cover (got first two years included) because it wouldn't let me do it online. This resulted in numerous emails/phone calls after they initially referred me to VW customer services who referred me to VW Financial Services who then referred me back to customer services who referred me back to the dealer.
The car is fantastic but at times it is more hassle than what it is worth. Thanks for the advice guys ...
-
Just last week my GTi went for a inspection with pollen filter, and guess what.. same 25% left and lip developing on disc, but because they were making noise which was annoying me I stupidly agreed to do it there and then and forgot to ask for old parts to have a look. As a bonus they did oil service for free :grin: but only because technician tought its inspection with oil and because I never said so they never charged me :evil:
BTW is it £319 for discs and pads with labour? Because I thought performance models are excluded from that fixed price