GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk6 => Golf mk6 GTD/TDI => Topic started by: Redsal4U on 04 March 2013, 22:51

Title: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Redsal4U on 04 March 2013, 22:51
Hey, i'm looking to purchase some new boots for my GTD. It has Conti Sport 2 all round which may have been the stock tyres (only done 19k) but they will need replacing soon.

What would you recommend for good dry and wet weather handling / braking and would not also break the bank?
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Mr GTD on 04 March 2013, 23:15
Well I run Goodyears F1 Asymmetric 2's which I have found awesome, plenty of members on here run them too...
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Keithuk on 05 March 2013, 02:27
Well my standard tyres are Bridgestone Potenza RE050 and I've read many reports the people say these are noisy but I don't find them noisy. I've just bought 2  Bridgestone Potenza RE050A - £100 fitted for the front. I had a puncture but they said it wasn't worth repairing with 3mm on, the MOT was comming up so I had 2 tyres fitted at 18.5k they would have done 20k.

I searched around to tyres and I was thinking about:

Michelin PRIMACY 3 225/45 R17 91W with rim protection ridge (FSL) - £105 - Roll resistance: C, Wet grip: A, Noise emissions: 69 dB.

As they are better in the wet and are supposed to be quieter.

Bridgestone Potenza RE050A 91 W - £100 - Roll resistance: F, Wet grip: B, Noise emissions: 73 dB.

Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 225/45 R17 91Y - £92.30 - Roll resistance: E, Wet grip: A, Noise emissions: 69 dB.

I've heard plenty of reports that Dunlop tyres are noisy.
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Raffe on 05 March 2013, 07:23
Agree with Keith on the RE050A's, run them on both my MK5 Golf GT Sport diesel and also my Leon FR diesel and love them as a good all rounder.

Get 18-20k out a set of fronts and around 36-38k out the rears before the dreaded sawtooth sets in.

They have a stiffer side wall than the GY F1's which gives a handling feel I personally like, and I don't find the, particularly noisy and spend hours at a time on the motorway.

Tyres are quite a personal thing though so what I may like will be different to many others.
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Redsal4U on 05 March 2013, 08:43
Are the RE050A's Run flats as these tend to firm up the ride and with the state of British roads can become increasingly uncomfortable.

I like the sound of the Eagle F1, as they seem better in the wet. Will it make much difference to the tyre selection based on rim size? I'm running 18" on 225/40's

Any recommendations where to buy or is it a case of phoning around to get the best deal... any forum members who have some contacts would be greatly appreciated.

A quick pic of my GTD on a icy morning in the midlands.

(http://i1283.photobucket.com/albums/a556/Redsal4u/IMAG0051_zpsab5bd151.jpg)
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Keithuk on 05 March 2013, 12:56
Are the RE050A's Run flats.

No RE050A's aren't run flats.
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Mr GTD on 05 March 2013, 16:06
Well my standard tyres are Bridgestone Potenza RE050 and I've read many reports the people say these are noisy but I don't find them noisy. I've just bought 2  Bridgestone Potenza RE050A - £100 fitted for the front. I had a puncture but they said it wasn't worth repairing with 3mm on, the MOT was comming up so I had 2 tyres fitted at 18.5k they would have done 20k.

I searched around to tyres and I was thinking about:

Michelin PRIMACY 3 225/45 R17 91W with rim protection ridge (FSL) - £105 - Roll resistance: C, Wet grip: A, Noise emissions: 69 dB.

As they are better in the wet and are supposed to be quieter.

Bridgestone Potenza RE050A 91 W - £100 - Roll resistance: F, Wet grip: B, Noise emissions: 73 dB.

Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 225/45 R17 91Y - £92.30 - Roll resistance: E, Wet grip: A, Noise emissions: 69 dB.

I've heard plenty of reports that Dunlop tyres are noisy.

Are the RE050A's Run flats as these tend to firm up the ride and with the state of British roads can become increasingly uncomfortable.

I like the sound of the Eagle F1, as they seem better in the wet. Will it make much difference to the tyre selection based on rim size? I'm running 18" on 225/40's

Any recommendations where to buy or is it a case of phoning around to get the best deal... any forum members who have some contacts would be greatly appreciated.

A quick pic of my GTD on a icy morning in the midlands.

(http://i1283.photobucket.com/albums/a556/Redsal4u/IMAG0051_zpsab5bd151.jpg)

Looks good with the Vanc's...best colour too :cool:

For 18inchers your pay around £120 a corner for the F1's...if I remember correctly I paid £460 fitted which is £115 a corner and that was from my old Suzuki dealer...

There's plenty of companies that will probably do you a better deal if buying 4...

MyTyres (http://www.mytyres.co.uk/)

Black Circles (http://www.blackcircles.com/?stop_mobi=yes)

Camskill (http://www.camskill.co.uk/)

To name but a few...probably best to phone a few near you also.


Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Redsal4U on 05 March 2013, 16:54
i'll try a few next week.. is there much of a difference in tyre wear miles between the RE050 and Eagles F1's :undecided:
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: ajmoir36 on 05 March 2013, 21:49
Micheln Pilot Sport 3s wipe the floor with the Bridgestones anyday.
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: cosmicremedy on 15 April 2013, 14:37
Micheln Pilot Sport 3s wipe the floor with the Bridgestones anyday.

Ah first mention i've seen on Pilot Sport 3's.... Had them on my Clio 182 and they were great, wasn't sure how they would be on the GTD though?
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: ajmoir36 on 15 April 2013, 21:36
Good, my first pair lasted 17,000 on the front, now on all 4 corners. A lot quieter than the Bridgestones too and £135 a corner slightly more expensive but I think worth it.
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: cosmicremedy on 16 April 2013, 11:44
Good, my first pair lasted 17,000 on the front, now on all 4 corners. A lot quieter than the Bridgestones too and £135 a corner slightly more expensive but I think worth it.

Probably end up going with these when i need a change in a couple of months...
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Jules Winfield on 25 April 2013, 21:26
Can anyone with the Goodyear Asymmetric 2s tell me what the noise levels are like with these tyres?  I have Potenzas on my GTD currently and they are deafening.  I am eyeing up a set of Assymmetric 2s as a replacement, despite the Potenzas not being fully worn, and the only thing that's holding me back is the noise level - I don't want to spend £400 or so on new tyres for them to be as bad as the current ones.
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: Dipesh2031 on 20 April 2014, 00:51
I have Bridgestone potenza S001's and they're quite harsh, love the grip though, find them quiet on the road and motorway too
Title: Re: Best Rubber for GTD 170
Post by: mcmaddy on 20 April 2014, 08:36
Still can't see why everyone raves about the pilot 3's. Can someone explain why they never come out top of any comparisons but everyone thinks they are the best tyre since sliced bread.