GolfGTIforum.co.uk
Model specific boards => Golf mk5 => Topic started by: Snoopy on 27 June 2012, 08:36
-
Thinking of moving to an edition 35 and as its the same engine iirc as the edition 30.
Has has there been any common known issues with it as its been out quite a number of years now and so they should have shown themselfs by now. If i do move to one its quite a financial step so the car will be with me for 10 years or so, so known its engine weeknesses now would be benificial in making the decision.
-
I seriously wouldnt bother.... unless of course you plan on remapping. The K04 has noticable lag over the k03 and doesnt feel anywhere near as lively as the std gti. The k04's are a great platform for modding, as Im sure you know, but in std form they really offer nothing major.
I would also imagine the consumption would be a major factor. In my mk6 I got a nice 34mpg average with blasting around where possible (remapped). With my std ED30 I am looking around the 30mpg mark.
... and I must add that most my miles are now done during quiet times on the road... but not quiet enough to blast about as I did in the GTI. I would say you are easily looking at 6mpg difference, and quite a financial increase for a run out car.
As for your inital question.. the engine is generally considered much stronger than required and has know know problems itself. After all it a detuned S3 engine and still used in the Golf R running 270bhp as std.
-
Just buy the Edition 30 . The ED35 is not a limited edition and to pay all that money for it when it is no different to the ED30 is madness . If you had the money sitting in a bank account it would be madness , to borrow money to buy it would be ********* . There isn't a word to describe how stupid this would be.
-
Agreed, bank the dosh, buy a high spec spec DSG ed30. why spend another 15k for what you've already got in the mk6. It's the same car , different turbo and different wheels.
At least with an older car, you know it's not gonna rust after 6 months like your 6 did :laugh:
-
Mine never rusted as protected from day one but a used edition 30 on the other hand..
Each to their own but i much prefer the look and interior of the 6 over the 5 and if the Edition 30 is a proven engine with by now should be known weeknesses(what i wanted to know what they were) then i would keep the ed35 10 years+ anyway. Ive had the mk1 21+ years for example.
-
Mine never rusted as protected from day one but a used edition 30 on the other hand..
Each to their own but i much prefer the look and interior of the 6 over the 5 and if the Edition 30 is a proven engine with by now should be known weeknesses(what i wanted to know what they were) then i would keep the ed35 10 years+ anyway. Ive had the mk1 21+ years for example.
I thought the plan was you were keeping your current 6 for 10 years?
sounds like you have a itch to spend on a new car :wink:
personally , I'd buy a year old R instead of a 35. Better looking and ticks every box :wink:
-
I would agree... the R is so much more than the 35.
I wouldnt expect any mk6 to last 10years :lipsrsealed:
-
My money would go to the .:R too Snoopy :smiley:
-
Wait two months for the mk7. It's a genuine new car, not just a rehash like the mk6.
Here is a quote from Autocar 3 weeks ago...
The all new, Mk7 Volkswagen Golf GTI has been spied undergoing final testing before an expected showroom launch early next year. The all-important GTI is rumoured to be powered by a 260bhp turbocharged 2.0-litre petrol engine and will get the firm’s new VAQ front differential for “more agile steering behaviour”.
Insiders say this VAQ unit, which consists of an electronically controlled Haldex clutch of the kind usually found in four-wheel drive systems, would allow the new car to lap the Nürburgring faster than today’s GTI even if it didn’t have any extra power.
-
If your planning on keeping the next car you purchase for 10 years then I would hang on for a mk7.
Got a feeling it's going to be a cracker with the new platform :wink:
-
Ex Demo Ed35 at Pullman Sunderland near you, go for a test drive and see if you think it's an improvement to what you already have.
http://www.pulmanusedcars.co.uk/used_volkswagen_golf_20-tsi-gti-235ps-edition-35-dsg-5-dr-ex-demo-sunderland_2622.htm
-
If your planning on keeping the next car you purchase for 10 years then I would hang on for a mk7.
Got a feeling it's going to be a cracker with the new platform :wink:
Yep and its going to have 260BHP :grin:
Geoff I would get an R over the ED30 mate. :cool:
As for faults I only had one on mine which was funny chirping noise on cold start (cam belt and pulleys replaced on warranty) :rolleyes:
-
I had thought about the R
But there is loads of them in Newcastle and Durham also the new haldex has had a few issues.
I also prefer the GTI looks but that's a personal thing.
Mk7 if it has the electric handbrake like the new a3 , no thanks hate them and more trouble than there worth.
-
Just buy the Edition 30 . The ED35 is not a limited edition and to pay all that money for it when it is no different to the ED30 is madness . If you had the money sitting in a bank account it would be madness , to borrow money to buy it would be ********* . There isn't a word to describe how stupid this would be.
I don't think the ed30 was limited, it was supposed to be but they sold around 2200. The ed35 probably will sell less as there's only around 150 on the road now so it will be a rare gti in thw future. BTW I must be mad I bought a ed35 but I dont care ;-)
-
I seem to remember you saying the standard gti was laggy so I dont know what you'll make of the 35. Me personally love mine and it feels more special than a standard gti. Would you be buying brand new ? As I may sell mine if anyone's interested, only through lack of use, less than 2900 miles in 8 months
-
What are you having it for? If it's for an investment then you might look at the ED30/35 as to the right enthusiast they carry more prestige, but to the general punter you take the R.
-
I had thought about the R
But there is loads of them in Newcastle and Durham also the new haldex has had a few issues.
I also prefer the GTI looks but that's a personal thing.
Mk7 if it has the electric handbrake like the new a3 , no thanks hate them and more trouble than there worth.
Yes its more or less the same thing in the Tig still dont like handbrake button, but I love the autohold :wink: