GolfGTIforum.co.uk

General => General discussion => Topic started by: Optimus Wol on 28 April 2005, 10:51

Title: cant decide.....
Post by: Optimus Wol on 28 April 2005, 10:51
since going to the track day down castle combe, i've come to the conclusion that im gonna do a project. problem is, i cant decide whether i wanna do a mk1 or a mk2. as i cant decide, im gonna leave it to you lot  :smiley:

answers on a postcard please.................
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Overseer on 28 April 2005, 10:55

is the project for a track car?
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Flying Custard on 28 April 2005, 11:06
If you're gonna do it propperly i'd say the mk1, smaller, lighter and prob as or more agile than a mk2... and of course with a silly engine in, nothing less that a 16v lump i'd say...  :cool:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Optimus Wol on 28 April 2005, 11:14
i was thinking of doing a track car, but its eventually gonna be an everyday car, so i gotta stay practical. big engine transplant though  :grin:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Overseer on 28 April 2005, 11:19

MK3 cab :D


out of the two choices above... mk2...


Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: gibby on 28 April 2005, 12:09
mk1 for all the reasons that Flying Custard mentioned.  :grin:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: mix on 28 April 2005, 12:20
mk1 for all the reasons that Flying Custard mentioned. :grin:

and then the custard will fly.........if you buy a yellow one.... :huh:

i would go mk1 aswell
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: davero on 28 April 2005, 12:21
i would go mk1 purely for aesthetic reasons
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Dinky on 28 April 2005, 18:17
mk1..everytime :cool:

Dinx :kiss:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Mr Blue on 28 April 2005, 18:21
mk1's and 2's are done. I would say do a mk3 cab as mentioned
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: VeeDubGTI16v on 28 April 2005, 18:52
for a track day car mk1 stripped with a 16v on carbs or throttle bodies :laugh:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Agreeable Slick on 28 April 2005, 19:18
mk1s and 2s are done for a reason blue, they are light, agile and have the right posture and handeling for a track car. Mk3s are too lardy and you need to invest far more into them to get the same gains as you would get out of a mk1/2 for half the price.

I would say mk1, with a mk2 16v engine, on throttle bodies, or ported and polished, balanced and lightened fly should see you with nearly 200bhp at the fly, and 165-170 atw no problems.
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Bronze MK1 Cab on 29 April 2005, 08:37
MK1  :evil: You f*cking knows it clart  :wink:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Optimus Wol on 03 May 2005, 11:09
^^ no need to get aggresive chris.....  :grin:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Flying Custard on 03 May 2005, 11:19
MK1  :evil: You f*cking knows it clart  :wink:

 :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin:


And what slick said, but mybe with a 2.0 16v lump instead of the 1.8  :huh:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: tinman on 03 May 2005, 15:36
track day - mk1. weight is the killer.

i wouldn't touch a cab for any sort of track day work, and anybody who is suggesting it needs their brains tested. the only cabs that are worthwhile on tracks are the ones that were originally cabs from the start, and not the ones with the roof hacked off.

a cab will suffer from scuttle on a track, plus they weigh alot more than the standard mk1. as for a mk3 cab on a track - that has to be some sort of joke.

cant really see the point of a 2litre 16v though. the difference between 1.8 and 2.0 is top end, and you wont be going top end on a track. for decent acceleration you want to keep the stroke shorter so the 1.8 would easily suffice.
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: golfpro on 03 May 2005, 15:56
Youv got to do a mk1! If i had the time/money/knowledge/effort thats what id do.

Either that or id do a camper...

Id love one of those things!

Look at me goin off in my own world again, do a mk1!
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: sportline_velly on 03 May 2005, 16:01
mk1
fully stripped
caged
2.0 16v flowed head
kr cams
42mm inlet manifold
16v box with LSD

now that would be fun!!!!  :cool:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Judderi on 04 May 2005, 13:12
track day - mk1. weight is the killer.
cant really see the point of a 2litre 16v though. the difference between 1.8 and 2.0 is top end, and you wont be going top end on a track. for decent acceleration you want to keep the stroke shorter so the 1.8 would easily suffice.

Kinda disagree there mate, the 2.0 bottom end provides a hell of a lot more torque and bottom end power to the 16v - well worth the mod!

mk1 cos there the coolest closely followed by a mk2
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: mix on 04 May 2005, 13:53
track day - mk1. weight is the killer.
cant really see the point of a 2litre 16v though. the difference between 1.8 and 2.0 is top end, and you wont be going top end on a track. for decent acceleration you want to keep the stroke shorter so the 1.8 would easily suffice.

Kinda disagree there mate, the 2.0 bottom end provides a hell of a lot more torque and bottom end power to the 16v - well worth the mod!

mk1 cos there the coolest closely followed by a mk2

i agree there, the 16V has the torque higher up the revs and the 8V at the bottom end.......aslong as it is a 8V 2-litre.... if its a 16V 2 litre i agree with tin..... :huh: :undecided:
Title: Re: cant decide.....
Post by: Optimus Wol on 05 May 2005, 11:44
i guess im gonna do a mk1 then.....  :grin: i know for one going relatively cheap in cwmbran, so i'll go take a look when i get back from my hols.

hopefully there will be a new entry in the project section soon......  :cool: