GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk3 => Topic started by: Mike87Turbo on 06 February 2011, 17:31

Title: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Mike87Turbo on 06 February 2011, 17:31
Hi all, i know this may be the wrong area to ask  :laugh: but i think ill be swapping my Vectra Gsi for a VR6.
The problem is, which should i go for? The Mk3 or a Corrado?

Not sure if the power difference would be enough to warrant getting a coupe over the golf, but having said that im a 6 cylinder lover and do like a bit of power :D

If anyone can shed some light on the differences in the engines it would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance, Mike
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: F17BAD on 06 February 2011, 17:34
golf has 174bhp and looks the best i think

corrado one had 190 bhp, but im not a big fan of the shape of them
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: robz on 06 February 2011, 17:41
corrado will drive better! but parts are expensive, also a stunning looking car!
the golf is a golf, ya get what ya see!!!
owned both, still cant make my mind up lol
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: jonnypolish on 06 February 2011, 17:43
LOVE how fat the Raddo is!
They look perfect with some poke!
But i am partial to a 3  :cool:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Deano2711 on 06 February 2011, 17:48
Corrado ftw....will be worth more than the Golf all day long. Although the Golf's are a nice piece of kit as well  :wink:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: robz on 06 February 2011, 17:55
but the rado will cost ya more to maintain!!
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Christo77 on 06 February 2011, 17:58
No disrespect to the Corrado and their owners, it's a fine motor but i think you'll always be a bit better off with a Golf variant if you look on a wider perspective, and when it comes down to it you tend to be glad of those general moments when they arise..

My tuppence  :cool:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Wayne on 06 February 2011, 18:58
I would keep the Vectra.

The Vauxhall engine is a much better package than the VR6.
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: robz on 06 February 2011, 19:14
I would keep the Vectra.

The Vauxhall engine is a much better package than the VR6.

traitor lol
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Wayne on 06 February 2011, 19:21
I would keep the Vectra.

The Vauxhall engine is a much better package than the VR6.

traitor lol

Sorry but Vauxhall V6 has more power, no cam chain to worry about and is a lot lighter so they do not understeer as much.
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: robz on 06 February 2011, 19:45
lol
only joking mate, fair reason!
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: tdi_blu on 06 February 2011, 20:06
So given the choice Wayne you would rather drive round in a V6 vectra instead of a Golf VR or a Corrado VR  :shocked:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Wayne on 06 February 2011, 21:32
So given the choice Wayne you would rather drive round in a V6 vectra instead of a Golf VR or a Corrado VR  :shocked:

Vectra GSI yes not a standard V6 Vectra very different cars to drive, always wanted a GSI estate but too steep on the insurance for the miles I do, I can add that I have driven both and yes I guess you could say the Golf feels more solid to drive but they don't feel quick whilst the Vectra does, it is simple, easy and in a way cheap to get the Vectra up to 220 + bhp to do the same in the Golf will be a lot more expensive also you have the worry of cam chains which are mega bucks to fix, to do the cam belt on the Vectra is around £300 tops.

Corrado VR is a different animal and prices reflect that, good ones are climbing in value but would still pick a G60 or 16V as I think they truly reflect the market that the Corrado was aimed at when it was launched.
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: tdi_blu on 06 February 2011, 21:39
Thats cool vectras ent my cup of tea just remind me of taxis but still I respect your views.Its clear your into your cars BHP etc so why the Citroen Picasso or have you got something else a project of some sort?
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Wayne on 06 February 2011, 21:42
Thats cool vectras ent my cup of tea just remind me of taxis but still I respect your views.Its clear your into your cars BHP etc so why the Citroen Picasso or have you got something else a project of some sort?

I only do 2000 miles a year so for me these days as sad as it seems I don't need anything quicker, it is great for the bikes plus 35mpg and cheap insurance.
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: tdi_blu on 06 February 2011, 21:50
Thats fair enough not knocking it just curious really ive got the 7 seater Alhambra plus a bedford Rascal which is really handy  :grin:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Wayne on 06 February 2011, 21:54
Thats fair enough not knocking it just curious really ive got the 7 seater Alhambra plus a bedford Rascal which is really handy  :grin:

Bedford Rascal why ?
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: tdi_blu on 06 February 2011, 22:05
Me and my dad went Half wacks on it as we are going to do car booters.Its a 1990 G plate done 41,000 with History.Costs £200 fully comp for the both of us and its really cheap to tax plus very good mpg.I have used it to pick bits up and do regular runs to the local tip just a handy little van.When ive been out in it I have had 2 people ask me if I want to sell it  :grin:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Wayne on 06 February 2011, 23:17
Me and my dad went Half wacks on it as we are going to do car booters.Its a 1990 G plate done 41,000 with History.Costs £200 fully comp for the both of us and its really cheap to tax plus very good mpg.I have used it to pick bits up and do regular runs to the local tip just a handy little van.When ive been out in it I have had 2 people ask me if I want to sell it  :grin:

Fair enough, I have seen one fitted with a Honda CBX1100 Blackbird engine :smiley:
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: thai-wronghorse on 07 February 2011, 12:15
Me and my dad went Half wacks on it as we are going to do car booters.Its a 1990 G plate done 41,000 with History.Costs £200 fully comp for the both of us and its really cheap to tax plus very good mpg.I have used it to pick bits up and do regular runs to the local tip just a handy little van.When ive been out in it I have had 2 people ask me if I want to sell it  :grin:

Fair enough, I have seen one fitted with a Honda CBX1100 Blackbird engine :smiley:


Can of pure suicide right there ^^^
Title: Re: VR6 Dilemma...
Post by: Mike87Turbo on 07 February 2011, 13:01
Cheers for the input guys! Although im more confused than when i started lol!
I do want to keep the vectra but its the look of the dubs that im after! I knoiw the vectra is probably faster (mines running around 210bhp) but its not the same.
And after doing this conversion for the missus and driving the GTI 8v, its safe to say ive been bitten by the bug!