GolfGTIforum.co.uk
Model specific boards => Golf mk6 => Topic started by: Exonian on 09 November 2010, 16:02
-
Golf GTD vs Megane Diesel thingy
http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/carreviews/grouptests/259084/megane_gt_diesel_vs_golf_gtd.html?CMP=NLC-Newsletters&uid=8ce50d5bf2602b0f04c2949d5b5c08bc
-
Looks horrid, its rubbish, need we say anymore. Athough that does sound a little harsh. £23K I thought Golfs were expensive the Megane is like £10k over priced.
-
the old megans were ok imo. the new ones look horrid and the body is far too big for the wheels :undecided:
-
the old megans were ok imo. the new ones look horrid and the body is far too big for the wheels :undecided:
The old ones were quite cute.
The new ones look completely misshapen. They should have burnt the designer alive IMO.
They can't even give away these rotten cars.
Imagine seeing this every single day. I think most owners lose the will to live eventually. :evil:
-
Very surprised at the Golf GTD's lack of economy that they are quoting, which lets face it is the only reason you would choose one over the GTi:
* Price: £24,230
* Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 168bhp
* 0-60mph: 7.6 seconds
* AE economy: 38.1mpg
* Claimed CO2: 134g/km
My GTi is faster and more economical.
Must be a mistake :rolleyes:
-
Very surprised at the Golf GTD's lack of economy that they are quoting, which lets face it is the only reason you would choose one over the GTi:
* Price: £24,230
* Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 168bhp
* 0-60mph: 7.6 seconds
* AE economy: 38.1mpg
* Claimed CO2: 134g/km
My GTi is faster and more economical.
Must be a mistake :rolleyes:
Combined figure for a GTD is 55mpg
-
So you're getting more than 38mpg from your gti? Are you doing a lot of m way driving at 60mph or what?
Please let me in on the secret.
-
So you're getting more than 38mpg from your gti? Are you doing a lot of m way driving at 60mph or what?
Please let me in on the secret.
Only use Shell V power, on motorways use cruise control to keep revs below 3000 ( about 75 mph ) and can easily achieve 45-47 mpg.
Around town I see 33-38mpg.
I am sure that if I drove like Miss Daisy and at 56Mph I could achive 50mpg plus. One day I might try it if I have the patience.
I came from a Mk5 140bhp diesel that could do 55mpg on the same journeys ( same as per the claimed GTD figure ).
Remarkable that the GTi can get close to that.
-
So you're getting more than 38mpg from your gti? Are you doing a lot of m way driving at 60mph or what?
Please let me in on the secret.
Only use Shell V power, on motorways use cruise control to keep revs below 3000 ( about 75 mph ) and can easily achieve 45-47 mpg.
Around town I see 33-38mpg.
Must be a town without much traffic, I do mainly town driving and can't get it above 25.7 mpg. [I only use V-Power as well]
-
^i'm the same, 26-27mpg round town and about 44mpg doing normal motorway speeds, mixed driving style, i'm fairly happy with that but can still understand why some favour the GTD.
-
So you're getting more than 38mpg from your gti? Are you doing a lot of m way driving at 60mph or what?
Please let me in on the secret.
Only use Shell V power, on motorways use cruise control to keep revs below 3000 ( about 75 mph ) and can easily achieve 45-47 mpg.
Around town I see 33-38mpg.
Must be a town without much traffic, I do mainly town driving and can't get it above 25.7 mpg. [I only use V-Power as well]
Try the 8 mile run from West London to Kings Cross using the Marylebone Road in rush hour. 6-10 mpg between Baker Street and Kings Cross. Average speed 6 mph. :sick:
-
Very surprised at the Golf GTD's lack of economy that they are quoting, which lets face it is the only reason you would choose one over the GTi:
* Price: £24,230
* Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 168bhp
* 0-60mph: 7.6 seconds
* AE economy: 38.1mpg
* Claimed CO2: 134g/km
My GTi is faster and more economical.
Must be a mistake :rolleyes:
If that GTD gets 38.1mpg there must have been a hole in the fuel tank. I can't do that if I tried the worst mpg I have had was low 48mpg (calculated - none of this trip computer rubbish).
-
Same here ajmoir, even in my revo'd gtd I could driver like a lunatic and not get 38 mpg. 60 mpg on a road trundle easy
-
i'm ordering a gtd :undecided:
-
i'm ordering a gtd :undecided:
Yes and you wont regret it too :smug:
-
Very surprised at the Golf GTD's lack of economy that they are quoting, which lets face it is the only reason you would choose one over the GTi:
* Price: £24,230
* Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 168bhp
* 0-60mph: 7.6 seconds
* AE economy: 38.1mpg
* Claimed CO2: 134g/km
My GTi is faster and more economical.
Must be a mistake :rolleyes:
If that GTD gets 38.1mpg there must have been a hole in the fuel tank. I can't do that if I tried the worst mpg I have had was low 48mpg (calculated - none of this trip computer rubbish).
You guys need to think about this abit harder. :wink:
They performance tested the car. :nerd:
That GTD is there long term car thats often shown in the long term car section. This GTD is often quoted as ~45mpg average over the time with them, and we are not talking BS computer says numbers or miles to a tenner or one trip type. They do it the proper way brim to brim and miles covered. Then look at the last tank fulls average and work it out to date.
-
Very surprised at the Golf GTD's lack of economy that they are quoting, which lets face it is the only reason you would choose one over the GTi:
* Price: £24,230
* Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 168bhp
* 0-60mph: 7.6 seconds
* AE economy: 38.1mpg
* Claimed CO2: 134g/km
My GTi is faster and more economical.
Must be a mistake :rolleyes:
If that GTD gets 38.1mpg there must have been a hole in the fuel tank. I can't do that if I tried the worst mpg I have had was low 48mpg (calculated - none of this trip computer rubbish).
You guys need to think about this abit harder. :wink:
They performance tested the car. :nerd:
That GTD is there long term car thats often shown in there long term car section This GTD is often quoted as ~45mpg average over there time with it and were not talking BS computer says numbers or miles to a tenner or one trip type. They do it the proper way brim to brim and miles covered. Then look at there last tank full average and work it out to date.
Spot on thats why it says AE Economy ie Auto Express Economy.
I have alway kept a proper log of mpg on all my cars running costs. not that I drive for economy just like to keep track of my costs. :wink:
I am really happy with the GTD's mpg (My first Diesel). I just hit 2000 miles of mixed town/motorway driving and its returning 46.4mpg. In comparison My ED30 was returning 24.7mpg and the 350z 19.8mpg :sick: and Mini Cooper S 25.9 mpg :sick:.
Loved the ED30 but was costing me £350 a month in fuel. :embarassed:
GTD is working out at £200 a month. :shocked:
So I'm off to Austria for 2 weeks over christmas/new year with the money i've saved :evil:
-
I am really happy with the GTD's mpg (My first Diesel). I just hit 2000 miles of mixed town/motorway driving and its returning 46.4mpg.
Its a bit better then mine. But what is the mix percentage wise? Mine is 70% local running.
(http://www.fuelly.com/sig-uk/43490.png) (http://www.fuelly.com/driver/KeithUK/golf)
Other fuel sites are available but not as good. :wink: