GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk3 => Topic started by: -danisdubbin- on 31 July 2010, 21:31

Title: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: -danisdubbin- on 31 July 2010, 21:31
hey guys, ive been playing this idea over in my head a bit, speaking to various people on this forum, and a few i know in 'real life' lol

what do you guys reckon the best route for me to take is??

im playing with the idea of a audi 225 (1.8t) engine conversion in my 8v mk3

or

a vr6 conversion with a remap?

i spoke to a chap today who reckons im better off doing the vr6 conversion as its easier, cheaper, and can get similar results to the 1.8t conversion??

i understand the difficulties and costs of the 1.8t conversion, especially on a 8v, but i think it would be a 4/5 grand better spent than buying say an alfa gtv! as i LOVE my golf shell lol


anyways, any input from anyone who has attempted a vr6 / 1.8t conversion would be soooooo appreciated

cheers all

dan
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: Wayne on 31 July 2010, 21:38
A Vr6 even with a remap will be around 180bhp, 1.8t is a lighter engine and you can get 200+ bhp easy

1.8t would be my choice.

Have a read: http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=124485.0
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: -danisdubbin- on 31 July 2010, 21:45
A Vr6 even with a remap will be around 180bhp, 1.8t is a lighter engine and you can get 200+ bhp easy

1.8t would be my choice.

Have a read: http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=124485.0

yeh i have had a good look at this, its a banging thread .......

how much u reckon im gnna be shelling out for a 1.8t conversion, considering i can do all the upgrading to 16v parts myself wayne? a ballpark figure?
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: broken-passat on 31 July 2010, 21:51
do something different........G60   

it might be harder to find , but the sound of a G60 motor is second to none :laugh:
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: Wayne on 31 July 2010, 21:52
do something different........G60   

it might be harder to find , but the sound of a G60 motor is second to none :laugh:

Nope not worth the hassle, old school now plus supercharger issues.
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: -danisdubbin- on 31 July 2010, 21:52
do something different........G60   

it might be harder to find , but the sound of a G60 motor is second to none :laugh:

elaborate??? i like where this is going tho ........... g60 supercharger right, is this the one that come off the mini coopers?
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: Wayne on 31 July 2010, 21:53
do something different........G60   

it might be harder to find , but the sound of a G60 motor is second to none :laugh:

elaborate??? i like where this is going tho ........... g60 supercharger right, is this the one that come off the mini coopers?

Nope Golf or Corrado G60, really hard to find
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: -danisdubbin- on 31 July 2010, 22:01
so thats a no then ........ if it's gnna be solid to find??

plus rather than whack a superchrager on, id rather go for like a bit more of a project, would love to get my teeth into something proper.

Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: DrewGTI on 31 July 2010, 22:19
Most decent places will do you a 1.8t conversion and supply all the bits and give you warranty for between 4-5k! Piece of mind I guess!

Or you could find a good doner car and do most of it yourself and maybe get it done for around 2k plus! Lots of info here, edition38 and the like.... Or even a google search!

Out of all the times this kinda of thread comes up we must see the results zero pf the time!  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: zdebx on 31 July 2010, 22:39
VR6 conversion is pointless, because you can BUY a VR6...Unless, you are putting that engine into mk2 Golf or Polo or anything else, that is not easily available.

1.8T all the way ;)
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: Jimp on 31 July 2010, 22:57
VR6 conversion has a point if you have a very solid shell and the VR6s you can buy are rust buckets, but since there are so many VR6s in the UK that shouldn't be much of a concern.
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: jonnypolish on 31 July 2010, 23:55
1.8T... The VR isn't getting anywhere near 225bhp without a fair bit of work!
As Wayne has said, Lighter, Highly tuneable engine!
Would definitly buy a donor car and attempt this myself if:
a) I knew more
b) Had the time!
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: dom on 01 August 2010, 00:00
Just to repeat what has already been said in the thread, personally I don't see the point of dropping a VR6 into a Mk3 because you could just go and buy one for a lot less hassle. For me it's gotta be the 1.8T  :evil:
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: Dan_GTi8v on 01 August 2010, 21:19
My 1.8t conversion using an AUm engine going from an 8v GTi is looking to cost be under 2k, I think im looking at around 1800-1900. I am getting a few bits on the cheap though :)
Title: Re: 8v gti conversion vr6 vs 1.8t
Post by: -danisdubbin- on 01 August 2010, 22:03
My 1.8t conversion using an AUm engine going from an 8v GTi is looking to cost be under 2k, I think im looking at around 1800-1900. I am getting a few bits on the cheap though :)

omg, thats awesome?!!!

how are you getting this done so cheap, are u doing it yourself or are you gettin parts done by a garage mate??

is that AUm engine only 180 bhp?