GolfGTIforum.co.uk

General => General discussion => Topic started by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 11:13

Title: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 11:13
Hi guys, I'm really after a MK4 GTI (non turbo) and want some advice on them

Ideally I'm after a 1.8 NA, as I've heard the 2.0 is SLOW.

However, I'm also considering a 1.6S, are these any good? What is the performance like compared to the 1.8 NA?

Also, I'm looking to spend no more than 1600 - am I living in a dream world?
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Diamond Hell on 07 June 2010, 11:17
Whilst I can't believe I'm typing this, £1600 would get you a bloody good Golf3 16V, probably with air-con etc if you shop carefully.

This would probably provide you with a lot more entertainment than a G4, of any of those flavours.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: AlanD on 07 June 2010, 11:20
The 1.8 NA is technically faster than the 2.0, but neither are actually "fast".

I wouldnt bother with the 1.6S and if need be save a tiny bit more for a 1.8. Is there any reason other than budget for not getting a 1.8T?

For that price I would imagine your looking at 100k plus.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Wayne on 07 June 2010, 11:20
Whilst I can't believe I'm typing this, £1600 would get you a bloody good Golf3 16V, probably with air-con etc if you shop carefully.

This would probably provide you with a lot more entertainment than a G4, of any of those flavours.

 :shocked: are you feeling ok.

Would a better bet than a mk4 n/a 1.8 or 2.0
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Diamond Hell on 07 June 2010, 11:25
One has to move with the times and be realistic when discussing someone's requirements.

Let's face it, the Golf4 is the Golf3's chubby sister.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: AlanD on 07 June 2010, 11:26
Fat girls are more grateful.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: JC on 07 June 2010, 11:27
there speaks the voice of experience  :grin:
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Diamond Hell on 07 June 2010, 11:28
Fat girls are more grateful.

How does that translate car-wise?
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: AlanD on 07 June 2010, 11:29
The MK4 makes you feel ..... better ..... after taking a ...... a good corner . . . . :undecided:
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Diamond Hell on 07 June 2010, 11:31
Sometimes I think you need to drink more..... or less.  I'm not sure which.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Sam on 07 June 2010, 11:53
Whilst I can't believe I'm typing this, £1600 would get you a bloody good Golf3 16V, probably with air-con etc if you shop carefully.

This would probably provide you with a lot more entertainment than a G4, of any of those flavours.

(http://marketingadlibrarian.files.wordpress.com/2009/08/shocked.jpg)
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 12:15
I'm after a MK4 because it's newer, and more relaible. A MK3 would be nice, however I've got a MK2 at the moment and after spending nearly £3K for the car and repairs in the last two years - want relaiblity. I just don't know if a Golf3 will give me that.

The reason I can't afford a turbo is the insurance - trust me, i'd love one.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: dom on 07 June 2010, 12:20
I'm after a MK4 because it's newer, and more relaible.

Newer - Yes
More reliable - Debatable  :laugh:
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: AlanD on 07 June 2010, 12:21
I'm after a MK4 because it's newer, and more relaible.

Newer - Yes
More reliable - Debatable  :laugh:

lol just what I was going to say :D

A MK4 thats done over 100k could well be just as bad as your MK2 if its not been looked after.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 12:25
So do you guys think that a MK3 is a better option?
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Wayne on 07 June 2010, 12:36
So do you guys think that a MK3 is a better option?

Yep as your going to find a nice car for your budget, a mk4 will be a struggle.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: kells on 07 June 2010, 12:37
iv got both

mk3 every time

thing is, buy a crap unloved  mk 2, 3, 4 etc and it will have its problems


my mk4 was bought brand new and it has had alot of electrical issues, mostly wiring harness type problems, annoying stuff

my mk 3 was bought 4 year ago, didnt know its history or anything and cost peanuts really, and its never once let me down.. makes the mk4 look sh!t really :grin: the mk4 is alot faster tho but its a derv with a remap, had a 1.8t Mk4 before that and it was slow, about as slow as my 8v mk 3, and before that i had a mk 4 2.0 and that was slow too, nice to drive just slow

Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 12:39
What insurance group is the Golf3 16v. Bearing in mind i'm driving a Golf2 8V and it's costing around a grand at next renewall.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: Diamond Hell on 07 June 2010, 12:44
Get a quote is the best suggestion.
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 12:49
Sorry to be a pain mate - any idea what group they are, and what group the golf2 8v is? I'm at work so havent got time to trawl through google.

Cheers in advance!
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: kells on 07 June 2010, 13:01
lazy bar steward  :grin:

its a 14 or 15 group, cant remember which, think its 15 tbh
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: billy_vw on 07 June 2010, 13:08
15  :wink:
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 13:10
Whats the MK2 8v?

Cheers dudes.

I'm already on a top secret mission by posting on these forums! If my boss knew he'd go mad!
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: billy_vw on 07 June 2010, 13:30
Whats the MK2 8v?

Cheers dudes.

I'm already on a top secret mission by posting on these forums! If my boss knew he'd go mad!

Don't worry , we won't tell your Boss  :laugh:
Title: Re: After a MK4 - Need advice!
Post by: G60Limited on 07 June 2010, 13:42
So anyone know what insurance group the MK2 8V is? I'm hoping it'll only be a little bit lower than the MK3 16V and I can get that one!