GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk5 => Topic started by: Enforcer on 04 June 2010, 10:25

Title: Sound options...
Post by: Enforcer on 04 June 2010, 10:25
So got my gti yesterday - have to say loving it at the moment and the drive back was 'interesting'  :evil:

However the only small downside to the car is that it only has 1 cd slot and no changer / ipod / mp3 etc.

What do you guys typically do for OEM sound options - I'mguessing I've got options of...

1) Buy a RCD300 with MP3 player (my one doesn't have mp3)
2) Buy a 6 cd changer
3) Buy some kind of ipod interface
4) Buy a sat nav unit (does that have mp3?)

Which route have you guys gone down and which would you recommend?

Thanks for your help. :)
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Enforcer on 04 June 2010, 10:50
PS Ideally I would like to have a 6 cd changer and access to my ipod music on occasion...
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: AlanD on 04 June 2010, 10:54
If your serious about sound then the only proper alternative is aftermarket. I've got an Alpine HU with a small sub and amp. You cant compare it to a standard OEM setup.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: luvmygti on 04 June 2010, 11:04
The standard OEM sound system is fairly rubbish!  :sick:

The bird has a 02 plate punto. That sound system sh1t's on mine it has a standard sub built in the boot  :shocked:
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Hurdy on 04 June 2010, 15:03
I have to agree that the only way for decent sounds is to go aftermarket.

The OEM iPOD dock is a waste of time and money.
The OEM speakers can all be bought for less than £50, so imagine how cheap and nasty they are to actually make :sick:
The OEM head units specifically have VW sound processing to reduce the sound at certain volumes and frequencies as they know the stock speakers can't handle them
This is why an aftermarket head unit will sound better until the volume is wound up.

Even cheap aftermarket speakers are leagues better than the MKV OEM speakers.

The MKVI dynaudio system speakers are much better, but would cost you more than a decent aftermarket set-up. :cool:
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Jimp on 04 June 2010, 18:55
I have an aftermarket aux in connection in mine but I won't recommended it as another person on here got the same kit and it wouldn't work. We couldn't figure out why.
A full on aftermarket headunit would be a good start.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Enforcer on 04 June 2010, 21:34
Hmmm tough one, as I keep all my car sound system OEM - as opposed to inputs like CD players which don't bother me as they are typically hidden away.

In terms of ipod connections is the denilson the best bet (apologies if I misspelt the name there) ?
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Gene Hunt. on 04 June 2010, 22:15
Just got the standard head unit & genuine 6 cd changer in arm rest BUT mine is 05 & has the 10 speaker system & for me it's fine.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Enforcer on 08 June 2010, 22:11
Have any of you guys bought these "box units" from china which you put in the glovebox - they allow you to play music from SD cards, USB memory sticks or an AUX input (ipod) ?

They look like good value...
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Upperoilcan on 10 June 2010, 08:29

The OEM iPOD dock is a waste of time and money.

Without question THE worst £155.00 i have ever spent after having this fitted to my GTI by VW.

The worst Ipod connection bar none,Does'nt charge the Iphone (Although i was assured by the Salespig That it does).There is no display to show what you are playing on the radio interface,Even the ipod screen goes blank and only shows a VW badge.

All in all.....utter crap.



Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Lee_dub on 10 June 2010, 12:33
There is no display to show what you are playing on the radio interface

Now that I am very supprised about!

How do you change track etc? if you can't see what your doing
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Sootchucker on 10 June 2010, 17:17
It actually only show you CD (playlist no) and track number, i.e CD2 Track 12

No display of mp3 titles and no real safe way to seach through for anyo ther tracks that are not part of the first 5 playlists. VW really missed the goal on this one.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Lee_dub on 10 June 2010, 22:42
Won't be bothering with that then! You can get the media thing instead for the arm rest can't you? Like an aux port.

Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: snakehips on 11 June 2010, 07:53
Won't be bothering with that then! You can get the media thing instead for the arm rest can't you? Like an aux port.



Yup, when I bought my car I ripped out the crappy iPod interface and put in the proper MDI interface. I highly recommend it as it is fully integrated into the radio display, the highline display, and controlled by the MFSW if you have one. It will cost you though - approx £250.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Lee_dub on 11 June 2010, 08:19
was that fitted mate or just for the parts?

I can't wait to start speccing my MK5 up, I get it today  :smiley:
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Jimp on 11 June 2010, 14:57
If you're going to spend up to £250 on it you may as well take a look at some aftermarket headunits. There are some very OEM looking double din ones out there.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Lee_dub on 11 June 2010, 16:50
Na I think I'll get an RNS510 tbh
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: snakehips on 11 June 2010, 18:43
was that fitted mate or just for the parts?

I can't wait to start speccing my MK5 up, I get it today  :smiley:

£250 inc labour. Attached to RNS510 which I think is excellent. Maybe not the absolute best sound but it does everything you could ever need, especially with the Fiscon hands-free which I also threw in for good measure. And I reckon resale value will be slightly better if fitted with OEM kit.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Lee_dub on 11 June 2010, 20:40
Totally agree with you mate! OEM equipment always looks better, plus with the RNS510 you can really integrate all the media/phone etc
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Mr. Indecisive on 11 June 2010, 22:17
if you put the mdi interface through a mfd2 will it still display on the highline ??  or does it have to go through a rns510  ??
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: snakehips on 11 June 2010, 22:28
I think MDI will only connect to RNS/RCD510, but someone smarter than me can confirm.
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: dTEA on 12 June 2010, 07:36
The question was about sound quality no? The only way to truly improve that is changing speakers and headunit especially as the sound stage is awful on the UK mk5s. The front pods are in way the worst positions possible. You get very little from the low end and the mid is right next to your ear. If you are serious about sound then the US spec door cards are the way forward...but that is the next level, other than custom built door pods etc

http://www.talkaudio.co.uk/vbb/showthread.php?t=304442 (http://www.talkaudio.co.uk/vbb/showthread.php?t=304442)
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Jimp on 12 June 2010, 12:45
What is different about the US spec door cards?
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: dTEA on 12 June 2010, 20:32
the position of the lower and mid...they basically bring them all forward instead of the lower bass sitting right next to the bl00dy seat upright...
Title: Re: Sound options...
Post by: Lee_dub on 12 June 2010, 20:49
Apparently, according to my boot sticker anyways - I have the 10 speaker system.  I can only see 2 speaker areas on each door card so is there two speakers in one area? Also will I have the Amplifier installed from factory? if so where is it?

Sorry for all the questions