GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk5 => Topic started by: Trickyboy on 19 September 2009, 15:48

Title: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Trickyboy on 19 September 2009, 15:48
After 6 blissful months of cracking driving a recent change of career has resulted in an 80 mile a day commute so i'm seriously considering a derv....  :sad:
Anyone got any suggestions for an alternative? It's gotta be german, thinking maybe a 320d or an A3? The mk5 dervs just dont do it for me after owning a GTi...
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: robz on 19 September 2009, 15:53
think the a3 dervs have a bit of oomph!!
nice enough car too...
dont do a beemer!!
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: robz on 19 September 2009, 15:53
what about a new rocco derv???
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Trickyboy on 19 September 2009, 15:56
what about a new rocco derv???
the rocco dervs are probably a bit out of my price range atm tbh...
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: JC on 19 September 2009, 16:09
passat wagon  :wink:
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: dubcruiser on 19 September 2009, 17:04
Would go A3 170bhp if I were you. I drove one last week with the S-Tronic (DSG) box and it was impressive. We have a A3 Sportback 2.0T and performance wise there ain't much in it apart from 45mpg compared to 27mpg!!

Seat Leon also but it not everyones cup of tea... Cheaper though  :wink:
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: stokeballoon on 19 September 2009, 18:13
I had a MK2 Seat Leon FR TDi 170.  I was lucky to see 40-42 on a long run.  The DPF (diesel Particle Filter) hammers the economy. 

If I were you, I would buy a 140 TDi and map it up a touch, and drive the wheels off it!
 :evil:
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Saint Steve on 19 September 2009, 18:41
Stagecoach do good return rate Tickets.

Keep it!!!
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: VW BUSH on 19 September 2009, 21:45
X5 3.0 Diesel "Jagdpanther" 200bhp quick and handles (suprisingly)
38mpg around town more on Mway
Bit of a barge but i couldnt keep up in the SaaB Turbo Cab :shocked:

(http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/3552/photo003elv.th.jpg) (http://img7.imageshack.us/i/photo003elv.jpg/)
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Trickyboy on 20 September 2009, 20:49
What do you guys reckon is a good price to get for her? 56 plate, 25k miles, no real extras, 17" monzas, immaculate condition...  :undecided:
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Rhyso on 20 September 2009, 20:50
Stagecoach do good return rate Tickets.

Keep it!!!

I'd rather walk after seeing the state of their buses  :lipsrsealed:

Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Saint Steve on 21 September 2009, 08:13
What do you guys reckon is a good price to get for her? 56 plate, 25k miles, no real extras, 17" monzas, immaculate condition...  :undecided:
£12500 -£13000 ?
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: AlanD on 21 September 2009, 11:49
If I HAD to get a diesel and had the money I would get an A3 170 S-Line. The S-line kit REALLY sets it apart and its a proper smart motor. I was looking at the 140s before seeing the light and got the GTI.
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Rhyso on 21 September 2009, 12:07
If I HAD to get a diesel and had the money I would get an A3 170 S-Line. The S-line kit REALLY sets it apart and its a proper smart motor. I was looking at the 140s before seeing the light and got the GTI.

mate of mine had a white A3 Sportback S-Line - looked mint  :cool:
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Hurdy on 21 September 2009, 14:19
What do you guys reckon is a good price to get for her? 56 plate, 25k miles, no real extras, 17" monzas, immaculate condition...  :undecided:
£12500 -£13000 ?

Sounds about right to me :smiley:
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Hairy Porter on 21 September 2009, 15:50
What do you guys reckon is a good price to get for her? 56 plate, 25k miles, no real extras, 17" monzas, immaculate condition...  :undecided:
£12500 -£13000 ?

Sounds about right to me :smiley:

Yep that's the price.
 
Changing to derv might save you £1000 per year on fuel (over 18000 miles), I wouldn't bother changing car, but I think I would move house.
Title: Re: Maybe time to part ways....
Post by: Hurdy on 21 September 2009, 17:25
What do you guys reckon is a good price to get for her? 56 plate, 25k miles, no real extras, 17" monzas, immaculate condition...  :undecided:
£12500 -£13000 ?

Sounds about right to me :smiley:

Yep that's the price.
 
Changing to derv might save you £1000 per year on fuel (over 18000 miles), I wouldn't bother changing car, but I think I would move house.


Diesel would give you a decent fuel saving, but the depreciation would be more from a similar price base as the GTI will hold it's value . :smiley:

Your car at say £13k would still be worth £8k in 2 yrs, but a £13k derv would drop to around £5k in 2yrs.