GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk4 => Topic started by: Hugsee on 26 August 2009, 23:51

Title: Which GTI?
Post by: Hugsee on 26 August 2009, 23:51
I currently own a 1.4 Golf E but after falling in love with golfs (although mine isnt exactly the most exciting car out there) im looking into buying a GTI with the intension of tuning and eventually taking on track days and/or drag strips.

My question is which one? iv heard the 2.0 engine isnt as appealing as i first thought if i want to tune it for high performance and the 1.8T is the 'tuners choice'

Any advice is appriciated.
So what do ya think?
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: topher on 26 August 2009, 23:57
there really is no contest.. if you intend to tune it the 1.8T is the only option
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Wayne on 27 August 2009, 00:18
1.8t ftw.
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: DrewiD on 27 August 2009, 00:23
iv'e got a 2.slow,,, get the 1.8t if you can
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: jtomlin on 27 August 2009, 00:24
i feel sorry for all the 2.0 golfs in the world, they constantly get slated!!












after that... get a 1.8t
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: ABOO on 27 August 2009, 08:04
Even if you have no intention of modifying it go for the 1.8T mate :smiley:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Rhyso on 27 August 2009, 08:08
none of them - they're all crap!!!  99% of the threads on here are asking 'what's wrong with my poxy petrol engine'  :laugh: :laugh:

Get a TDI  :evil:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: ABOO on 27 August 2009, 08:16
Have to agree in some respects with Rhyso.

GTTDI golfs are amazing, even more so with a remap. Pull stupid money imo though. An ibiza 130 sport is much better value..
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Rhyso on 27 August 2009, 08:19
Have to agree in some respects with Rhyso.

GTTDI golfs are amazing, even more so with a remap. Pull stupid money imo though. An ibiza 130 sport is much better value..

:afro:

father-in-law has an Ibiza Sport (last shape) - quite a rare car by all accounts

Even in standard form its quick and certainly quicker than my Golf felt in standard form (thanks to the weight); he won't let me map it though to see HOW quick it can be  :sad:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: ABOO on 27 August 2009, 08:25
Rare but still a real bargain. Even been considering a move to the dark side myself as my milage is beginning to rise.

Even do a 160bhp version as std, which are very rare, and quick as fook std!! ie on a par with petrol version.

Personally would prefer 130 with remap though..
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Madmax on 27 August 2009, 09:23
What's the 1.8t (remapped) like against say, the R32? :evil:
Or against standard hot hatches like the VXR & Clio?
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Jkctr on 27 August 2009, 09:31
You will be very close to every other (standard) hot hatch out there, remember there is very little between a car that will do 6.5 to 60 and 7.0 to 60.
You are more likely to use 30-70 though.

Fact is you are more than likely to come up against mapped versions of the cars you stated and will be slower.

If you intend to do drag/track then the mk4 gti is probably not the best out the box car? Infact very few hatches are!
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Madmax on 27 August 2009, 09:34
You will be very close to every other (standard) hot hatch out there, remember there is very little between a car that will do 6.5 to 60 and 7.0 to 60.
You are more likely to use 30-70 though.

Fact is you are more than likely to come up against mapped versions of the cars you stated and will be slower.

If you intend to do drag/track then the mk4 gti is probably not the best out the box car? Infact very few hatches are!

Interesting, thank you. :smiley:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 27 August 2009, 10:38
none of them - they're all crap!!!  99% of the threads on here are asking 'what's wrong with my poxy petrol engine'  :laugh: :laugh:

Get a TDI  :evil:


What about your "I'm fed up with my car - I want to get rid" thread, though?!  :P  :D
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 27 August 2009, 10:57
What's the 1.8t (remapped) like against say, the R32? :evil:
Or against standard hot hatches like the VXR & Clio?


Mine is (well, was until my manifold starting blowing it's arse off :rolleyes:) SLIGHTLY quicker in a straight line than a standard Mk4 R32 (in the dry), but needed a few handling mods to compete on track.

For track work, I probably wouldn't consider anything French unless it's still under warranty, but the following I'd consider fairly handy cars:-

Clio 182 Cup/Trophy
Clio 197/200 Cup
Mapped Megane R26
Integra Type R (DC2)
Civic Type R (EK9 or EP3)
Mk4 R32
Mapped Mk5 GTI
Mapped Mk1 S3
Mk1 Elise
E46 M3/330
Mapped Mk1 Focus RS
Mapped Mk2 Focus ST
ZS 180 (SERIOUSLY! ;) - Not the ZR, though, they're proper sh*te)
MX5 (if you can get over the image, lol)  :D

Probably forgotten a few other good'uns, but that'll do for now!  8)
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 27 August 2009, 11:01
p.s.  DO NOT even think about the 2.0 8v!  115 bhp in 1236 kg = Not very quick car!  ;)
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: stevie boy 01 on 27 August 2009, 15:09
never ever heard as much s.... as this ... a mk 4 wee golf 1.8 turbo out doing a e46 m3 .. 346bhp .. top speed .. 155 .. restricted .. unrestricted .. almost 200mph... what are you smoking .. it must be good sh....  hope i get the chance to prove this to this guy .. all the best ...ha .. ha .. ha .
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Rhyso on 27 August 2009, 15:15
never ever heard as much s.... as this ... a mk 4 wee golf 1.8 turbo out doing a e46 m3 .. 346bhp .. top speed .. 155 .. restricted .. unrestricted .. almost 200mph... what are you smoking .. it must be good sh....  hope i get the chance to prove this to this guy .. all the best ...ha .. ha .. ha .

and where was it mentioned in this thread about a MK4 oudoing an M3??  :huh:

i think you need to stop smoking the sh!t!!
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Steve_PD on 27 August 2009, 15:26
Must be good skunk if your tripping  :grin:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: tg1 on 27 August 2009, 15:33
funny enough, if you go into the remapping thread there is a bit with me asking about getting the speed limiter removed, and rtec seem to think 180 would be the vmax?

Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Rhyso on 27 August 2009, 15:35
funny enough, if you go into the remapping thread there is a bit with me asking about getting the speed limiter removed, and rtec seem to think 180 would be the vmax?

2 things will stop you from getting there

1) Aerodynamics
2) Final gear ratio
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Hugsee on 27 August 2009, 16:12
Thanks for all the advice guys.

Helped me out alot  :cool:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: richw911 on 27 August 2009, 18:14
never ever heard as much s.... as this ... a mk 4 wee golf 1.8 turbo out doing a e46 m3 .. 346bhp .. top speed .. 155 .. restricted .. unrestricted .. almost 200mph... what are you smoking .. it must be good sh....  hope i get the chance to prove this to this guy .. all the best ...ha .. ha .. ha .

lo WTFl  :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin:  :lipsrsealed: :lipsrsealed:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: northeast_gti-t on 27 August 2009, 18:43
never ever heard as much s.... as this ... a mk 4 wee golf 1.8 turbo out doing a e46 m3 .. 346bhp .. top speed .. 155 .. restricted .. unrestricted .. almost 200mph... what are you smoking .. it must be good sh....  hope i get the chance to prove this to this guy .. all the best ...ha .. ha .. ha .

and where was it mentioned in this thread about a MK4 oudoing an M3??  :huh:

i think you need to stop smoking the sh!t!!
quality  :grin: :grin:
also take a trip to vision express obviously suffer from poor eyesight to!  :grin: :grin:
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: the_stink on 27 August 2009, 19:07
hahah was going t say clearly misse dthe point that 'for the track you would consider using the following'

oh dear , any way the 1.8t is a very tunable car and you can get 300bhp with the right and in a straight lien would prob do a R32 guess its all about what you want from it ?
Title: Re: Which GTI?
Post by: Leec22 on 27 August 2009, 21:23
never ever heard as much s.... as this ... a mk 4 wee golf 1.8 turbo out doing a e46 m3 .. 346bhp .. top speed .. 155 .. restricted .. unrestricted .. almost 200mph... what are you smoking .. it must be good sh....  hope i get the chance to prove this to this guy .. all the best ...ha .. ha .. ha .


never ever heard as much s.... as this ... a mk 4 wee golf 1.8 turbo out doing a SLK 55 AMG .. 354 bhp .. top speed .. 155 .. restricted .. unrestricted .. almost 200mph... what are you smoking .. it must be good sh....  hope i get the chance to prove this to this guy .. all the best ...ha .. ha .. ha .


 :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: