GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk3 => Topic started by: locin78 on 31 May 2009, 21:33

Title: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 31 May 2009, 21:33
Hi , i have a 1997mk3 2.0 16v gti, it has a prob between 3000 and 4000 revs it lacks power and judders i have to drop a gear and get it by 4000 revs so it stop's it can do this in all gears , and when just standing it tick's over not so well either it sounds like it miss but its not as it did this befor i changed the plug's leads ect can anyone help thanks .
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: Tuccy on 01 June 2009, 09:06
Hi there,
My girlfriends car done this too, it was intermittent, but usually between the revs you mention, chucked it onto vag com and it indicated a faulty lamba sensor, when we changed it, it cured the prob.

maby your having the same issue..

good luck
Thomas
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 01 June 2009, 16:55
Hi Thomas thanks i will look into this someone else did say it may be the mass air sensor but i'll leave that till last as it will cost a packet lol

thanks Nic
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: DazVR6 on 01 June 2009, 21:57
Wont be the maf as 16v's dont have one, they have a map senser which is actually part of the ecu.

 I'd start by getting the car checked for any fault codes and as mentioned in other threads those relays can be a cause of these issues aswell and wont do any harm to change em.

Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 02 June 2009, 20:08
i  have had it checked twice and no codes came up but they did recomend changing the lambda sensor so i will be this week end is see how it is after that then go from there...
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: rubjonny on 03 June 2009, 08:27
quick test for lambda, simply unplug it! if problem is solved you need a new one. if you disconnect it it reverts to a base map.  other thing it could be is ecu temp sensor, they can fail but still return values within a range the ecu expects, so no fault is flagged.  its the 2 pin white one on side of head, always go vag for these :)
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: nikkim53 on 04 June 2009, 14:53
I had the same problem with mine, got told all sorts of things it could have been (dizzy cap, fuel injectors, ecu/fuel relay) needless to say all got changed but still had the problem.

Have recently found out it was the air flow meter, changed that and the car has been running like a dream.

Try taking off the air flow meter plug and try to drive it !!

Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 04 June 2009, 21:30
i just plugged my vag-com 409-1 into my car it came up with position sensor to short or to open to ground, what evar that means but would this cause the problem i have with the car??????
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 04 June 2009, 21:31
for got to say the fault code was G69
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: Diamond Hell on 04 June 2009, 23:50
befor i changed the plug's leads ect can anyone help thanks .

So this problem has occurred since you changed the plug leads, yeah?

Swap 'em out for the old ones first, or a known-good set and then start pulling other things to pieces.
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: rubjonny on 05 June 2009, 12:20
G69 is throttle position sesnor, have a look at the wiring to the throttle body, they run along the back of the inlet and get cooked by the exhaust.  did you clear the codes first and recheck?
could be an old code that wasnt cleared after problem fixed
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: DazVR6 on 05 June 2009, 12:41
i just plugged my vag-com 409-1 into my car it came up with position sensor to short or to open to ground, what evar that means but would this cause the problem i have with the car??????

Sounds like its refering to the crankshaft position sensor not sure if it would cause a missfire but when i had problems with mine on my old 16v it would keep causing it to cut out and in the end it eventually wouldn't start at all.

Ooops i stand corrected!
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 05 June 2009, 21:40
i have had thisprob since i got the car i have changed , plugs, leads ,dizzy, air filter, petrol filter, ect
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 29 June 2009, 21:50
think i have sorted the prob the wires that run from the position sensor and go round the  back of engine , they are all cooked and need replacing so lets hope this sorts it!!!!

thanks  for everyones help Nic
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: Mikester on 29 June 2009, 21:53
have you tried scanning it with the engine running?

Mels polo showed the crank shaft sensor to give this problem of stuttering, but when the engine was running it didnt show the fault code as it didnt have the sensor fitted to it at all. But presumed it did when it was off? If that makes sense.
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: VW Mel on 29 June 2009, 22:13
have you tried scanning it with the engine running?

Mels polo showed the crank shaft sensor to give this problem of stuttering, but when the engine was running it didnt show the fault code as it didnt have the sensor fitted to it at all. But presumed it did when it was off? If that makes sense.

Yeah, mine would judder at any speed and then sometimes cut out aswell, i would then have to wait a few mins to get it strated as it would just turn over. I have changed all the plugs and leads and air filter and that seems to have cured the juddering and stalling but still sometimes it wont start :/

Going to change ecu relay next :smiley:
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 29 June 2009, 22:28
GET VAGCOM  of ebay and run it through a laptop well easy and cheap to use cost me £13 better than £80 at VW, you get the cable and disk thats how ai narrowed it down to my wires on my poss sensor.
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: VW Mel on 29 June 2009, 22:34
My car doesnt come up with a fault code lol, so just guessing atm :/
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 29 June 2009, 22:42
mine did not i tryed 3 diff places and they all said the same (no fault) i got the vagcom then it found the prob and my mate had a look and comfirmed it.
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: VW Mel on 29 June 2009, 22:50
What was the problem? did it come up with a code then?

Dunno why mine hasnt :/
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 29 June 2009, 23:20
mine would judder between 2500 and 3000 revs anything after that it would run better it would do it in any gear when i plugged the vag com in it came up with possition sensor i check it and the wiring the wiring us f**ked so my mate double checked it at his garage and comfirmed it was causeing the fault so its getting sorted on thursday!
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 06 July 2009, 18:03
right i replaced the wires and throttle body and sensor's and it runs a lot better just need to reset ECU  , its stopped juddering between rev's there is only a slight hesitation at 3000 revs for a split sec then its all ok.
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: Len on 06 July 2009, 20:47
Change the ECU relay! :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 08 July 2009, 22:23
it was my fuel relay thanks nic
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: ramjet on 26 July 2009, 15:53
Hey guys,

What number did the relay have on it.167 or 80?I am stomped with the same problem.Irritating jerking all the time.

Thank you for your assistance.

Ramjetvw
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: boneybradley on 26 July 2009, 16:05

What number did the relay have on it.167 or 80?

http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=74087.0 (http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=74087.0)  :wink:
Title: Re: Mk3 golf gti 16v , judders between 3 and 4000 revs
Post by: locin78 on 26 July 2009, 20:34
i think it was 80 on it its on the top row 2nd one in from the left. just take it for a run then feel them if 80 or 167 are cold then replace them if warm to touch then they should be ok.

Nic