GolfGTIforum.co.uk

General => The garage => Topic started by: d4w50n on 10 May 2009, 16:10

Title: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: d4w50n on 10 May 2009, 16:10
Just out of curiosity, in a 1.8 Mk3 Golf CL chassis, what other engines would potentially fit in there? Like would a 2L GTI engine fit in without me needing to modify the chassis?

Or is there any other types of engines from other cars that would fit?

I've heard of Corsa owners fitting Cavalier engines into their cars...
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: lewisvr6 on 10 May 2009, 19:25
if you get the subframe for a vr6 that goes straight in no problem, get the bigger brakes aswell then  :smiley:
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: danny_p on 10 May 2009, 21:59
any 4 cyl  vag group engine will fit,    allong with the v5 and vr6 and all of its derivatives

some of these engines will take more effort to fit than others tho
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: Mikester on 10 May 2009, 22:18
mk3 8v 16v VR6

Mk4 1.8t V6 R32

But as said, each will take more effort depending.

Would would also need as well as engine and gearbox, the brakes, rear discs etc etc. Fuel pumps, ecu etccccc

The mk3 conversions would be easier to bolt on. The mk4 ones are trickier.
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: danny_p on 11 May 2009, 01:41
immobs start to become a pita on later cars
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: d4w50n on 14 May 2009, 11:30
So on a standard CL, if I were to put a Mk3 GTI engine in there, I'd also need a gearbox from a GTI aswell? I take it this is because AFAIK, some GTI engines are 6 speed and my standard CL is only a 5 speed? Am I thinking along the right lines?
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: rubjonny on 14 May 2009, 14:23
depends what engine the cl has, your existing box may fit. MK3 gtis never had 6 speed box, all 5 speed :)
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: A7 UFO on 14 May 2009, 14:36
just buy either a GTi or VR6.  The cars are cheap enough that theres no point converting a lower spec car.
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: d4w50n on 16 May 2009, 20:55
depends what engine the cl has, your existing box may fit. MK3 gtis never had 6 speed box, all 5 speed :)

AFAIK, and I'll have to confirm this if I do into overhauling the engine further, mine is either engine code AAM or ANN. Bogstandard 1.8 engine, 5 speed, bought as a "doing up" project for a decent price.

Would the gearbox from this work alongside a 2.0 16V GTI engine if I did want to do an overhaul?

Obviously, I'll first start looking at replacing suspension, brakes, exhaust, air filter, wheels etc with decent parts and finish the cosmetic side of the car (it's just begun a paint job) before I invest any serious money into the engine, but any info you guys have on converting a standard CL to a GTI engine is very helpful and much appreicated :-)
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: danny_p on 16 May 2009, 21:02
 abf's make short work of 020 boxes if you drive it like you should, thats why the abf and vr6 got o2a boxes from factory 
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: d4w50n on 16 May 2009, 21:37
Probs best replacing the gearbox aswell as the engine then I guess, can just buy them one by one and fit them both later on...

Anyone fancy joining me for that weekend project lol?
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: d4w50n on 16 May 2009, 21:43
What about engine codes AUQ/AWP (from Mk4's)?

Would they work with an 020 box in a Mk3 CL? and would the engine fit?
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: Ben Lessani on 16 May 2009, 22:49
Unless the car is particularly special - why not just buy a ABF MK3?

Faffing + insurance = expensive.
Title: Re: Fitting new engine question for the pro's out there
Post by: danny_p on 17 May 2009, 01:42
ABF = easy swap  but you really need a donor car as a LOT of parts are diffrent.  so sell car add the money you would have spent buying a decent donor to this and buy a good mk3 16v  it's also a lot quicker and less hasstel.

the first rule of enigne conversions is never build what you can buy and it's proven true over and over

if your determined to use the car put a 20vt or somethign in you chouldn't buy it with as the enigne will dowm as a mofication on your policy you may as well make it worth it