You need to sell that Jag
I'm not sure if I missed something but why do you have the Jag and the R ?
There's obviously a reasonable explanation ( other than just being flash )
The Golf is too small, and is a 3 door. They are very different cars, my wife doe not like the Golf, Its not as comfortable, I drive faster (apparently) and its louder.
If I'm by myself its the Golf all day long, but for a comfortable drive with the family in tow, its got to be the Jag. It also gets a real world MPG combined of 58mpg