s3 is old, changing model soon (u wont feel special),
bmw is aging, reface soon, golf new, not many gti's on road. its new, its fresh, , next to the mark 5 looks fresher, moderner. s3 feels old thats because it is. gti holds it value very well, very very well. but colour is next factor, white is nice but not good when you sell, best colours(i never go any other even if i want to ) is black, silver, nothing else and must be metallic. leather is good but mine is work car so i didn't bother. 18 inch monza shadows is a must if you're getting a gti. white isnt good. if you check any brand ie audi, vw..... and look second hand, not many of these blacks, silvers as they're more deireable and hold value more. also bright colours attract more bird crap especially red- fact!!
the manual gearbox is very good. the stereo as standard is the worst- only 8 speakers, my previous golf tdi had 10 speakers.
I meant to say its thcoupe, new shape. No reface due soon dude. I think its more tempting than the GTI now.
[/quote]