Totally agree, some cars give more a sense of theatre or occasion than others which may well be more competent.
Maybe you like ringing a type R round to 8k revs and the drama and sound that brings (I did). Each to their own.
My m135i is undoubtably the fasted car I have owned, is it the most fun? Not at all.
The feeling you get is the everything really and everyone has their own subjective parameters that give them 'that feeling' and hence the debate - There is no debate technically and factually but feeling has its own subjective sliding scale
When moved from the Audi S Line Quattro to the GTD there was never really that feeling of being in something special, the feeling was of great all around competence but I was still looking out of the windows at other cars and mainly the R
The R immediately gave me that special feeling and not many cars in my price bracket that looked over to with any wishing, and the thinking is that the TCR will match that feeling, for slightly different reasons, but no less a feeling.
My personal favourite car that owned briefly was a RS2000 which may sound great now, but it was not in best condition, and not that great to drive due to that, but it was a RS2000 and as a young lad thats actually all cared about
The very first thing thats going to be nice to say to anyone who slightly cares is that driving a GTI as them words have been a long time coming and to see their instant recognition opposed to the slightly blank expression on pronouncing that drive an R will be a nice change also
Wife is most excited about the climate screen and said she is already abandoning her A1 on the colder days for my heated seats and climate screen
But nice little discussion, enjoyed everyone thoughts on what makes them have a passion for cars.