I'd also agree with what somebody else said above - the cloth seats, particularly the bolsters and the material on the door cards - is crap IMO. It's the main reason I'd personally spec leather / art velours in the car - the "pleather" you get on the door cards isn't wonderful either but at least it wears very well.
Interesting views - we sold our 70k 3 year old MK7 GTD and genuinely the seats looked as good as new. Even with having a couple of dogs in the car.
When I was looking at R's or GTi's with leather, cars with 20k miles on had seats that looked f**ked! Stretched leather and large indentations.
In my experience - having had cars with both - the leather / pleather wears and ages far better. For example, on a wet day if the door card got wet when opening window or whatever, I'd notice that the rain would leave visible water marks on the door card / side of seat bolsters. They always seemed to get scruffy looking and hard to keep looking well (and I am extra anal about car cleaning so it wasn't through lack of care).
The pleather wipes clean and with a dab of glipitone leather cleaner, always looks and smells great.
You obviously don't agree. Hey ho.
Having said all that, regardless of upholstery, its mostly down to how well its minded. I've seen cars with only a few K on them with very scruffy interiors, both cloth and leather (dealer demo's and the likes).