Rebecca, you are constantly on the same page as me. Freaky. I was just about to post with a similar question. Perhaps he has not shut his door properly. Otherwise, he needs it adjusted.
Regarding my front doors, I am nearly there. Just need a little more TLC. I want both sides to look similarly hung. When a car is a touch wonky, it is quite a task. Just the passenger front door needs a tiny (less than 0.25mm) drop now and it will be perfect. Will be done on the 26th May when the car goes in to have a keyless immobiliser fitted.
Are we always on the same page?
I think it's most likely JB's door is not closed properly. Hope so.
Glad your door dilemma is heading towards a resolution. Tbh, a 0.25mm difference would bug the hell out of me, once you've noticed it that's it. On my mk6 one of vertical rubber window strips is a couple of millimetres short of the top and every day it's the first thing my eyes are drawn to.
That lovely shiny door just doesn't look closed to me. 
I think that's what it is too, but given there have been one or two with this issue, just wondered.
