ad 1) So the handheld sat nav uses the roof antenna for signal.... Interesting.
ad 2) VW used to make you take advanced phone on the mk7. If they stopped it on the 7.5 I wouldn't know; haven't configured a FL model. My current car's not up for replacement for another 18 months.
ad 3) OK, if that is your observation - great. My observation was different, number of satellites was usually a few less and signal strength was a little lower. You only need 4 satellites to have a signal, the more the more accurate though.
Just saying if you have lower signal then it may drop out a little sooner. How much will also depend on the model of phone or sat nav you are using I guess, whether that uses mobile data to substitute location info, has an external antenna....
Using the word 'cripple' was a dramatisation. And I think we probably really confused the OT.