well in turns of looks, scirocco wins hands down in my opinion.
went to the dealer to finally sort it all out. they had exactly the spec i wanted in both cars gti and scirocco.
the first time i saw a gti was with xenons and without these, the car looks bog standard golf no real life into the detailing im afraid and the one they had was a black metallic 3 door with 18s - yet it stil looked boring. then the viper green scirocco was there and this looked so much more entertaining. i know i will get slated for saying this on this particular forum especially, but ive been a fan of both gti and roc for ages now. also the gti spec price compared to that of the roc which had leather and sunroof etc was ridiculous.