EDIT: I think I know the problem. The part number on the back of mine is 1J1721647A, which I think is for a LHD car, whereas the part for a RHD car is I think 1J1721647C. From doing some reading it seems that the LHD one is slightly bigger, which would explain it.
Anyway I'm not too keen to fork out again for another pedal, and even if I was I'm having difficulty finding any RHD ones for sale at the moment. So I was thinking of maybe just gluing my R32 cover over the existing pedal cover. It fits perfectly, but it just won't stay in place securely. Any reason why I shouldn't do this or any recommendations for an adhesive that would be suitable?
Thanks!