whilst the S3 is faster, has 4wd, the better brand and arguably better build quality... sorry but its does looks really really boring. much as every M Sport BMW has cheapened the look of the M-series, the S-Line Audis have cheapened the look of the S3.
the mk vi gti just looks so much more up to date. i was shocked whilst in the vw dealersship that when i walked between the mkv and mkvi golfs, how much the mkv seemed to have dated.