I was thinking the exact same thing a couple weeks back (but may end up getting an S3 facelift). For me, I'd go for the clubsport. Looks better, sounds better, will be worth more when you sell it since its a rare care and its faster/more driver focused. The bad points are you won't get the facelift upgrades, but compared to the clubsport they are mainly interior. The big miss will be no Active Info Display depending of if you really like it or not. I see the recommendation for the gti facelift is to not upgrade to Nav Pro, so the standard Nav on facelift GTI is pretty much the same as Nav Pro on the clubsport but you'll get fingerprint marks on it (and it might be faster but not confirmed). Saying that, nothing wrong with the standard MIB 2 nav on the pre-facelift. A tougher decision is Clubsport vs Facelift R.