If the vacuum pipe to the dash was split or disconected, the sensor will see less or no vacuum. Why would that make your mpg look higher?, I thought that the lower the vacuum (throttle open) the less mpg, higher vacuum more mpg. Sounds like a faulty sensor, easy check of the pipe and connection to the dash, unplug the pipe at the engine and suck it. If you can suck thru if, split or disconected, if you can't faulty unit. Eather way, dash out to fix.
Steve.