ah well was a nice thought
Not a fan of LCD units as its simply a screen and O/S and in not too distant even the most budget makes and model will have them as standard - great for manufacturers though as have to produce one unit only and just have some configuration in software for the model.
The Golf dials are not a great case as an example, but if was losing the S3 dials for a screen not be overly happy.
So that's me very much in the dial camp, but do work in tech industry, surrounded by this kind of thing and have a house full of tech, so its not like I am anti in general, and maybe could be more swayed if the LCD screens that were seeing were not so flat and uninspiring - Have seen displays that really pop, just much more dimensional and attractive, these genuinely look like they are from a PS4 game and can definitely see budget makes not having anything less.
But its a new roll out, sure the developers will update the software.
Also given my MIB unit has had black screen moments, its not a moment you would want from your display
Personally think once there is a saturation of car market with soulless solid state tech everyone will be clamoring for dials again or be happy they still have them
Its subjective, can see how some will want, but definitely not missing out to point of a retrofit, go spend money on a holiday somewhere