GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk6 => Topic started by: wlscullion on 10 December 2008, 00:11

Title: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: wlscullion on 10 December 2008, 00:11
Thinking of changing my current Mark 5 GTI in next 12 months or so. Had a test drive in Audi S3 and was impressed but disappointed it does not come with Audi equivalent of DSG. Would be very interested in reported new R version of Mark 6 Golf. Anyone have any info on this ? In particular I am wondering is 4 wheel drive system in Golf R32 is essentially similar to quattro system used by Audi or is it fundamentally different. If I understand things correctly Audi sytem sends power 60/40 to rear/front wheels until traction is lost then according to which wheels have best grip whereas VW system gives 100% to front wheels until traction is lost. Can anyone tell me if I am correct and is this likely to make a noticable difference to driving charecteristics
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: topher on 10 December 2008, 09:05
Yes the 4wd system is the same haldex driven equipment as the S3, its more like 90/10 until it needs it though with a maximum of 50/50, and that isn't switched when traction is lost it kicks in when it senses a rotational difference of as little as 0.15 revolutions between front/rear which can occur on bends/corners when the front wheels still have full traction. Only the longitudinally engine mounted 4wd cars such as the passat 4mo and A4 quattro use a torsen differential based 4wd system which gives different handling characteristics. However there are only very limited details of the 'R' version of the mk6 golf. It will most likely share the same 265ps engine as the S3 but as yet I've seen NO concrete evidence to suggest it will be 4wd. Also the DSG version will probably be the new 7 speed version rather than the one you're used to.

To be honest I'm very much in the same boat as you, if neither the range topping Golf or Scirocco live up to my expectations I'll be visiting Audi. For your info the sportback S3 is available with DSG.
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: wlscullion on 10 December 2008, 23:10
Thanks that is useful info , will await furter info on new Golf R
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: AlanD on 20 December 2008, 14:26
I fear you may be waiting some time.
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: dan_apps on 20 December 2008, 18:48
^^wont be any news on this til they see how sales of the std GTI go i expect!
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: barry-gti on 22 December 2008, 20:07
Yes the 4wd system is the same haldex driven equipment as the S3, its more like 90/10 until it needs it though with a maximum of 50/50, and that isn't switched when traction is lost it kicks in when it senses a rotational difference of as little as 0.15 revolutions between front/rear which can occur on bends/corners when the front wheels still have full traction. Only the longitudinally engine mounted 4wd cars such as the passat 4mo and A4 quattro use a torsen differential based 4wd system which gives different handling characteristics. However there are only very limited details of the 'R' version of the mk6 golf. It will most likely share the same 265ps engine as the S3 but as yet I've seen NO concrete evidence to suggest it will be 4wd. Also the DSG version will probably be the new 7 speed version rather than the one you're used to.

To be honest I'm very much in the same boat as you, if neither the range topping Golf or Scirocco live up to my expectations I'll be visiting Audi. For your info the sportback S3 is available with DSG.


 :huh: thats jibberish to me lol, im such a beginner
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: Snoopy on 23 December 2008, 17:30
Thinking of changing my current Mark 5 GTI in next 12 months or so. Had a test drive in Audi S3 and was impressed but disappointed it does not come with Audi equivalent of DSG.
Im sure i spotted 's tronic' on the configurator for the S3 yesterday? I could be wrong. I also think i spotted it in a advert for the S3 in a recent weekly motoring mag.
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: AlanD on 24 December 2008, 09:43
S3 came with the 'S-Tronic' (DSG) option as of 1st October this year. Its a 7 speed one at that.

http://luxvelocity.typepad.com/luxvelocity/2008/09/audi-s3-gets-s.html
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: dubcruiser on 27 December 2008, 13:10
As above, it got added for the 2009 model with the release of the Sportback S3....  :smiley:
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: smbVW on 27 December 2008, 14:37
FYI, both S3 and Sportback S3 are available with S-Tronic though i don't know whether it is the original 6-speed or new 7-speed...I suspect the former as I understand that the 7 speed isn't capable of coping with high torque and power as yet...still in design stages!

EDIT: latest brochure confirms it is the 6-speed S-Tronic on the S3...
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: Edition30 on 20 January 2009, 17:54
Would be interesting to see if it does come with the same set up as the S3, think thats where the ED30's lack. Too much power and not enough grip...god knows what 300+ hp is like on the front wheels.
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: illyun on 20 January 2009, 23:46
Too much power and not enough grip...god knows what 300+ hp is like on the front wheels.

My Edition 30 is running at 321 bhp.  Plenty of grip (in the dry), but not enough power which is why its going for Stage 2+ and 360bhp next week  :evil: :evil: :evil:  Oh the Quaife LSD being fitted by VW Racing will probably help too   :laugh: :laugh:
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: R32UK on 27 January 2009, 19:57
Too much power and not enough grip...god knows what 300+ hp is like on the front wheels.

My Edition 30 is running at 321 bhp.  Plenty of grip (in the dry), but not enough power which is why its going for Stage 2+ and 360bhp next week  :evil: :evil: :evil:  Oh the Quaife LSD being fitted by VW Racing will probably help too   :laugh: :laugh:

Thats just nuts illyun!!! Looking forward to seeing the end results though :grin:
Title: Re: Mark 6 GTi-R or Audi S3
Post by: illyun on 29 January 2009, 12:05
Too much power and not enough grip...god knows what 300+ hp is like on the front wheels.

My Edition 30 is running at 321 bhp.  Plenty of grip (in the dry), but not enough power which is why its going for Stage 2+ and 360bhp next week  :evil: :evil: :evil:  Oh the Quaife LSD being fitted by VW Racing will probably help too   :laugh: :laugh:

Thats just nuts illyun!!! Looking forward to seeing the end results though :grin:

Every little helps  :wink:  The end result will probably be 2 bald front tyres after a couple of runs at Santa Pod and then 6 points (one for each tyre) on the way back home from the event  :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: