I dont see the advantage of this over the gallery. BUT how about something slightly different..
A sticky topic at the head of each mk section, where EVERY post must contain a picture of the relevant mk golf. So if you want to comment on a picture, you either have to take a photo yourself or find a pic of a sweet golf on the net and post it along with your comment. This would build up a good stock of pictures of each variant golf so every time someone posts "anyone got a pic of a mk2 on porsche wheels" etc.. they can just look in that thread.
Simples rules such as no posting the same pic twice, no quoting, no pics of the wrong type of golf, no posts without pics.. posts breaking the rules get deleted instantly. Whatcha think ?
Oh and anyone wanting to post arty picturesque photos, or photos of cars other than golfs, yer in the wrong forum